I have to say I went back to the jingly distorted other one and thought ........ my god, the guitar sounds so much better without the distortion, then I re-read Farview's post and came to the same conclusion - it's just a really awful distortion. So sizzle and jingly it just fills the entire thing up. Without it, there are other instruments that sound good, balance that is easier to hear - just that dreadful spectrum filling unsympathetic, nasty sounding distortion. Seriously though, you made a good guitar sound worse with it.
I know I'm old, but if I had that sound, I'd keep it. Then, as typing this, the other guitar came in with it's dreadful70s thin distortion - played a few bars then cleared off for a coffee. The distortion just doesn't work - for me. The solo guitar also has this very thin - weedy distortion. It sounds a little like the colorsound fuzz pedal I had in the 70s.