First off, congrats on losing the writer's block. Keep playing!
Wow - I liked the song a lot. Actually I loved it - didn't sound clumsy to me (except for one spot at 33 seconds - you could patch in to fix that one spot?). Perfect length for the song. I dig the triplets and stuff. I'm mainly a guitarist myself, and have been playing guitar for many years. Your emotion comes out well through your fingers.
It may not be recorded as hifi as some other people's stuff, but I actually think the relative lofi works better on this one anyway. Kind of makes the guitar sound like a harpsichord. GO AHEAD, MOZART! I could see this on a professional album as a "cool" or "retro" sound or something.
I listened to it a bunch of times. I want more!