SilverSurfer said:
It takes me about 15 seconds to get a good tone from a Marshall. Why does it take 2 hours for Mesa?! Uh, I think the answer is obvious.
the answer IS obvious. you are biased and think that mesas suck for some reason. you think that because you and some elitist friends don't like them, that they must suck.
just because you don't like something doesn't mean it has no worth.
YOU dont like it. leave it at that. there are thousands of people out there who love their mesas.
i spent a couple of years trying to get the sound i wanted from marshall equipment. when i got my triple rectifier, i got the sound i wanted. i no longer had to mess with distortion pedals or EQs. my entire distortion sound came from the head and my guitar only. i plugged into a dual rectifier to try them out for the first time, to give it a shoot out against my marshall. after 15 seconds i knew i had to get rid of my marshall and get a mesa. luckily a family friend was selling a triple for 900
i had people in my home town ask me how i got my sound and i just told them... it was all in the mesa and having a good guitar to back it up. that is about as simple as it gets.
some people like the marshall sound, some like the mesa sound. thats the facts. the best way to know what this guy should get is for him to try both amps and see what he likes best.
also... just for some added information. i used to work with my father servicing amps when i was younger. most of the new marshalls i worked on (anything with a light up rocker switch) were cheaply made and sloppy in comparison to the mesas i worked on. not to say that marshalls are crap, im just saying "in comparison."
mesa goes all out when they make their amps. they use good quality parts, everything is mounted securely. they're hard as nails. though, recently they were using some really shitty volume and tone pots which have since been replaced i think.
i haven't seen mass produced amps built that well aside from those that were made in the "golden age."
marshalls and mesas are both great amps. they just have a different sound, and you are more likely to have small quality issues with a marshall than you would a mesa.