I never spent time at big consoles, and never went for cassette portastudios. I pretty much stopped doing music about the time my buddy got rid of his 80-8 and Model 5 mixer. I got back into it with the AW16G, which had volume faders, but EQ/Compressor/Reverb were done from a single set of knobs after you selected the channel.
I don't have any issue with working with a screen. I've spent 3 or 4 hours tweaking, listening, tweaking, listening. I like having 15-18 faders for volume and each channel labeled so I don't have to remember what track is what. (don't have to remove any masking tape residue either.)