Monitor upgrade

Eric V

Eric V

Member at-large
I couldn't find a better subforum so I put this thread here. Mods please move as you wish.

Currently I'm using 5" Mackies, but I think I'm ready to consider a major upgrade. I do home recording on Reaper and Pro Tools and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 interface.

Any ideas? Thanks.
 
I'm sure there are people here who are much better authorities than I am on this stuff. But this is the internet, and what is the internet if not one giant excuse for all of us to get over our skis a little?

So, my PERSONAL thoughts are I'd really prioritize getting something with an 8" driver that's flat to at least 40hz, if possible below. Yes, I understand that there ARE designs that pull this off with, say, dual 5" drivers, and it's not quite as simple as this... but a full-size driver is a pretty easy starting point for your search.

I've been using a pair of Yamaha HS80s for a VERY long time now, and the newest version, the HS8, is definitely in your price range. But there's a lot of other good monitors in that range as well so I'll simply say that I've had them for probably fifteen years now and they've been very reliable in that time and I've been very happy with them. At some point I do want to replace them with something nicer, but that's going to involve spending a fairly material multiple of what this set cost me, and I don't want to do that until I've got my room a little better treated than it is now. And down the road this is something you'll probably want to think about too.. but for now, just getting a decent set of monitors with full extension down through 40hz will get you a long way and you can tackle your room over time, too.
 
OK - it's also worth thinking about the music you want to record? Low percussive bass and big kick drums benefit from bigger drivers as a general thing - but some people like subs. Personally, I don't. As I was typing drew suggested 8" drivers and my favourite monitors have 8" drivers and are 45 years old - Celestion DL8. I bought some Adam A7's for my other studio and I don't like them as much. They're great, but the bottom end is sort of a bit 'wrong' - not bad, just not like things (especially synths) sound. Do you live anywhere that you can listen to some, or maybe listen to friends, or even a local college where they do music? Taking a music file you know well will usually sound good, or not so good. Speakers are the worst things to buy on other people's advice - way too personal. My friend has Adams, he likes them, and in the music we played in his studio, I bought mine. In my studio, on my music - I'm just OK. Not bowled over.
 
I knew nothing about studio monitors.
I just thought if you spend a sufficient amount of money, you'll get better than crap.
The policy worked with my first stage piano (Kawai MP9500), and it worked with my
first studio monitors (Event TR8), which are still in use.
No way could I afford £100,000 monitors. Yes, you can pay that much.
Certainly look at 8", and somewhere near £1000.
If I ever replace my TR8s, I'd look at Adam, and ribbon tweeters.
ATC are reckoned to be good, and seem to come at ridiculous professional prices.
If you can, take your recorded music to a store with switchable monitors on display in a listening room.
 
My question is why do want "better" monitors? Do I smell GAS?

These days many studios both home and pro often mix in cans and Mackie monitors do a dang good job. Is bigger better...sure but is it really going to make on lick of difference in your final product...likely not And mastering you're going to want to listen through multiple speaker systems to find that sweet spot.

You didn't mention if you are using a sub with the mackies or which 5" mackie model you are using.

If you are currently not using a sub that should be a priority for the 2.1 stereo sound.

This guy is saying mobile phones are the NS1's of modern music



The EMIT app is way cool

I use can's most often. Once I get my studio interior finished ( in the year 2525)
I'll break out my Behri 2036 A's and a sub for the monitor system..Then again I am actually hoping to transition into dolby atmos!

I wish you good luck and just be careful that you're not "GASSING"

Getting good mixes will improve the more you are actually recording and not being distracted by next years model.......But wait! There's more! :laughings:
 
Currently I'm using 5" Mackies, but I think I'm ready to consider a major upgrade. I do home recording on Reaper and Pro Tools and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 interface.

Any ideas? Thanks.


It seems to me that you’re getting good mixes right now with your Mackies.

That tell me that you ‘know’ those monitors.


What ever you get to replace them, I’d say this.

Disclaimer: unsolicited opinion from just another guy. :)


Get something that if vented the port is in the front not in the rear.
Check with people whose mixes you like and see what they’re using.
Whatever you get be prepared to spend hours learning them.

And lastly don’t listen to me. I still am using my beloved Yamaha NS10s.
:D
 
I'm sure there are people here who are much better authorities than I am on this stuff. But this is the internet, and what is the internet if not one giant excuse for all of us to get over our skis a little?

So, my PERSONAL thoughts are I'd really prioritize getting something with an 8" driver that's flat to at least 40hz, if possible below. Yes, I understand that there ARE designs that pull this off with, say, dual 5" drivers, and it's not quite as simple as this... but a full-size driver is a pretty easy starting point for your search.

I've been using a pair of Yamaha HS80s for a VERY long time now, and the newest version, the HS8, is definitely in your price range. But there's a lot of other good monitors in that range as well so I'll simply say that I've had them for probably fifteen years now and they've been very reliable in that time and I've been very happy with them. At some point I do want to replace them with something nicer, but that's going to involve spending a fairly material multiple of what this set cost me, and I don't want to do that until I've got my room a little better treated than it is now. And down the road this is something you'll probably want to think about too.. but for now, just getting a decent set of monitors with full extension down through 40hz will get you a long way and you can tackle your room over time, too.
Thanks Drew!
OK - it's also worth thinking about the music you want to record? Low percussive bass and big kick drums benefit from bigger drivers as a general thing - but some people like subs. Personally, I don't. As I was typing drew suggested 8" drivers and my favourite monitors have 8" drivers and are 45 years old - Celestion DL8. I bought some Adam A7's for my other studio and I don't like them as much. They're great, but the bottom end is sort of a bit 'wrong' - not bad, just not like things (especially synths) sound. Do you live anywhere that you can listen to some, or maybe listen to friends, or even a local college where they do music? Taking a music file you know well will usually sound good, or not so good. Speakers are the worst things to buy on other people's advice - way too personal. My friend has Adams, he likes them, and in the music we played in his studio, I bought mine. In my studio, on my music - I'm just OK. Not bowled over.
Thanks Rob! I don't need subs, I don't do dance music or any of that. It's rock in general. Classic covers and lots of originals that cover the same kind of sonic ranges. No, I don't live near any places to try anything out and no friends I know have speakers I can try, but you made some really good points. Thank you.
I knew nothing about studio monitors.
I just thought if you spend a sufficient amount of money, you'll get better than crap.
The policy worked with my first stage piano (Kawai MP9500), and it worked with my
first studio monitors (Event TR8), which are still in use.
No way could I afford £100,000 monitors. Yes, you can pay that much.
Certainly look at 8", and somewhere near £1000.
If I ever replace my TR8s, I'd look at Adam, and ribbon tweeters.
ATC are reckoned to be good, and seem to come at ridiculous professional prices.
If you can, take your recorded music to a store with switchable monitors on display in a listening room.
I looked up £1000 and USD that's about $1,300. Out of my league currently. I need to stay in the $500-700 or $750 range. Like I told Rob, there aren't any options like that near me. Closes place with any monitors is about 40 miles away and I have no vehicle at the moment. A friend might be able to take me there, but it's a Guitar Center and I don't know if they would carry high end or medium end monitors.
My question is why do want "better" monitors? Do I smell GAS?

These days many studios both home and pro often mix in cans and Mackie monitors do a dang good job. Is bigger better...sure but is it really going to make on lick of difference in your final product...likely not And mastering you're going to want to listen through multiple speaker systems to find that sweet spot.

You didn't mention if you are using a sub with the mackies or which 5" mackie model you are using.

If you are currently not using a sub that should be a priority for the 2.1 stereo sound.

This guy is saying mobile phones are the NS1's of modern music



The EMIT app is way cool

I use can's most often. Once I get my studio interior finished ( in the year 2525)
I'll break out my Behri 2036 A's and a sub for the monitor system..Then again I am actually hoping to transition into dolby atmos!

I wish you good luck and just be careful that you're not "GASSING"

Getting good mixes will improve the more you are actually recording and not being distracted by next years model.......But wait! There's more! :laughings:

I suppose it's GAS, but I just feel I could step it up a notch in hearing the music I'm mixing better with an upgrade. And if I actually do end up getting some monitors I would have two (actually three sets) of monitors because I have a pair of Mackies, my friend does whose monitors we are using currently, and then new ones if I go that way.
 
Last edited:
It seems to me that you’re getting good mixes right now with your Mackies.

That tell me that you ‘know’ those monitors.


What ever you get to replace them, I’d say this.

Disclaimer: unsolicited opinion from just another guy. :)


Get something that if vented the port is in the front not in the rear.
Check with people whose mixes you like and see what they’re using.
Whatever you get be prepared to spend hours learning them.

And lastly don’t listen to me. I still am using my beloved Yamaha NS10s.
:D
:DThanks RFR, points well-taken. Thanks.

And thanks to everyone who has responded!
 
I was very, very fortunate several months ago to be able to buy a pair of Neumann KH-150 monitors. These replaced a pair of Tannoy Reveal 5A speakers so, a woofer size increase from 5" to about 6.5" but, it is not all about woofer diameter! Much larger cab than the Tannoys and way more amplifier power plus sophisticated DSP. The result is a quite astounding LF performance in terms of extension (~35Hz) and sound level. I have to say though that apart from the obvious bass improvement I was not immediately struck by a vast difference between the two makes. Now, having listened to the 150s for a long time I tend not to "hear them" any more IYSWIM! I just hear "a piano" or "a guitar" or "a soprano"...nothing gets in the way.

But OK, way out of OP's budget so to beat the bogey of a good LF performance the usual (partial) solution suggested is headphones. I have a pair of closed back Sennheiser 480 pro and they sound remarkably similar to my monitors. Open backed cans are usually said to be of greater fidelity and I read that Neumann themselves make the NDH 30s and they are even closer to their monitors, as one would expect?

Headphones are not the total solution for mixing, for one thing the spacial effects are "wrong" compared to speakers but maybe keep the existing monitors to get THAT right but check the LF end with some good cans in the $500 area?

Dave.
 
I was very, very fortunate several months ago to be able to buy a pair of Neumann KH-150 monitors. These replaced a pair of Tannoy Reveal 5A speakers so, a woofer size increase from 5" to about 6.5" but, it is not all about woofer diameter! Much larger cab than the Tannoys and way more amplifier power plus sophisticated DSP. The result is a quite astounding LF performance in terms of extension (~35Hz) and sound level. I have to say though that apart from the obvious bass improvement I was not immediately struck by a vast difference between the two makes. Now, having listened to the 150s for a long time I tend not to "hear them" any more IYSWIM! I just hear "a piano" or "a guitar" or "a soprano"...nothing gets in the way.

But OK, way out of OP's budget so to beat the bogey of a good LF performance the usual (partial) solution suggested is headphones. I have a pair of closed back Sennheiser 480 pro and they sound remarkably similar to my monitors. Open backed cans are usually said to be of greater fidelity and I read that Neumann themselves make the NDH 30s and they are even closer to their monitors, as one would expect?

Headphones are not the total solution for mixing, for one thing the spacial effects are "wrong" compared to speakers but maybe keep the existing monitors to get THAT right but check the LF end with some good cans in the $500 area?

Dave.
Thanks Dave! I did think about a headphones upgrade instead initially. I will definitely keep your points in mind as I go forward with plans.
 
Thanks Dave! I did think about a headphones upgrade instead initially. I will definitely keep your points in mind as I go forward with plans.
Happy to be of some small assistance. Note, when looking at headphones, the "pro" models tend to have replaceable cables (the 480s do) and ear pads. These are the things that fail on cans but otherwise they can last for decades so it makes sense I feel to invest well. The other weak point in the system can be the headphone amplifiers in interfaces and an external amp can add power*, quality and often be able to drive several sets. The Behringer HA-400 is ~$30 and I think sound pretty damn good.

* But take care not to bugger the lugs! Take the cans off frequently and check that your can's level is comparable to the monitor's and that should be in the 75 to 85dBC range. The SPL meters in phones are not calibrated but at least they give you a standard comparison . Also look up "Calibrating Studio Monitors Speakers".

Dave.
 
Happy to be of some small assistance. Note, when looking at headphones, the "pro" models tend to have replaceable cables (the 480s do) and ear pads. These are the things that fail on cans but otherwise they can last for decades so it makes sense I feel to invest well. The other weak point in the system can be the headphone amplifiers in interfaces and an external amp can add power*, quality and often be able to drive several sets. The Behringer HA-400 is ~$30 and I think sound pretty damn good.

* But take care not to bugger the lugs! Take the cans off frequently and check that your can's level is comparable to the monitor's and that should be in the 75 to 85dBC range. The SPL meters in phones are not calibrated but at least they give you a standard comparison . Also look up "Calibrating Studio Monitors Speakers".

Dave.
Great stuff Dave, thanks. I will look that up. As for a headphone amp I have a Behringer HA-400 and I agree, it works great.
 
I couldn't find a better subforum so I put this thread here. Mods please move as you wish.

Currently I'm using 5" Mackies, but I think I'm ready to consider a major upgrade. I do home recording on Reaper and Pro Tools and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 interface.

Any ideas? Thanks.
Well if you can find them used Mackie HR624 (Not the Mk2 version) are great. I don't really like the HR824 even though the 8"woofer is a little better than the 6" HR624
 
  • Like
Reactions: TAE
Well if you can find them used Mackie HR624 (Not the Mk2 version) are great. I don't really like the HR824 even though the 8"woofer is a little better than the 6" HR624
That's what I've had for over 15 years.
I was reluctant to recommend as they're only 6" but I've never really felt a need to upgrade from them,
in a home studio setting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TAE
That's what I've had for over 15 years.
I was reluctant to recommend as they're only 6" but I've never really felt a need to upgrade from them,
in a home studio setting.
As I said, it is not just cone diameter that decides LF quality or indeed quantity, like an car engine, "swept volume" matters as well. WRT to the 150s I had long promised myself some really good speakers for home listening but even modest "hi fi" speakers are way overpriced IMHO. Also I wanted actives as they would integrate with my home setup. I use a smart TV for nearly all sources. TV sound of course but Radio 3 and CD/DVD via HDMI cables. The TV sends S/PDIF to an Audient Nero monitor controller hooked in with my MOTU M4. This is all in my living room and I sit 2m away on a sofa. Monitors tend to last for decades and son (who does record) will get them when I am gone or even more ga-ga than now.

Dave.
 
I think a sub isn't just for dance music. IMO, since we have been in the digital age for 40ish years, bass has taken on a new place. If you look at how bass was handled in vinyl days (not just how it was processed, but the limitations on play back, needle bounce), then when digital came along, bass took a more prominent postilion. I do non EDM music, but I am becoming more and more bass sensitive. I think my monitors do well with the bass, but I think my 5.1 system does extremely well. Gives the bass more energy.

My main point is, don't blow off a sub just because you aren't going to thump. Bass in the right mix really is what I love about modern stereo and have a really hard time listening with HPs. Just another POV.
 
I think a sub isn't just for dance music. IMO, since we have been in the digital age for 40ish years, bass has taken on a new place. If you look at how bass was handled in vinyl days (not just how it was processed, but the limitations on play back, needle bounce), then when digital came along, bass took a more prominent postilion. I do non EDM music, but I am becoming more and more bass sensitive. I think my monitors do well with the bass, but I think my 5.1 system does extremely well. Gives the bass more energy.

My main point is, don't blow off a sub just because you aren't going to thump. Bass in the right mix really is what I love about modern stereo and have a really hard time listening with HPs. Just another POV.
From what I have read about subs there are a lot of poor ones about? I don't know if "Subaru Man" translates on a mainly US forum but the driver's sound systems are characterized by a one note thud. Many of the budget subs have poor linearity and though they might be delivering a bit of 40Hz they are also spewing harmonics up the spectrum to muddy up mid range sound.

Now that I go a good octave below the Tannoys (which weren't at ALL bad!) and with plenty of juice I find the lower bass region of many sources a stupid mess. My first..BRIEF! Listens to Radio One made me think " these speakers are way too bass heavy" But no, on Radio 3 the instruments are just as I expect them to be but! If now and again the guy hits the big orchestral drum I know about it! Movies and adverts also have an awful lot of LF rubbish in them. Not "toons" just someone effing about on a synth.

Dave.
 
Back
Top