
ausrock
Well-known member
God Han, you can be a dick sometimes..................I don't recall Alan ever claiming the clip was his and if you bother to check the link he posted to the clip it leads straight to John Mayers..................DUH!!!


Han said:Alan, with all due respect, but why did you run around in circles before you posted this? It may be that the recording of that clip belongs to someone else?
Using the same type Mayes guitar, PA-2 preamp, C4, and etc would help in copying that Mayes/C4 sound clip... but, I think your right about "many factors" and expecting the same "exact" sound... but, he will get closer to copying that Mayes/C4 sound clip with the same gear than he would trying to copy it without using the same gear.alanhyatt said:I never said the clip was mine Han! I said here is a clip of C4's on acoustic guitars. We have many more of those as well in our possession. As I said before, the reason I did not reveal the gear is if you go to that thread you mention where John posted it. A fellow HR poster wants to buy John's TL Audio P2 so he can get that exact sound. Read it Han...This is exactly what I did not want to happen, and why I was hesitant to reveal what gear it was. I even said this would happen in one of my posts!
The poster claims his C4's are now bad because he can not get that same sound, so he wants to buy John's P2. So what I said would happen....happened. Some guy now thinks the same gear in his hands and house will do the same thing.
You know that is not the case and he is wasting his money. Too many factors involved. That is why I simply put the clip up for the sole purpose of letting people hear a good clip with the C4's. Now it will turn ugly. Last time I ever put up a clip!
DJL said:Using the same type Mayes guitar, PA-2 preamp, C4, and etc would help in copying that Mayes/C4 sound clip... but, I think your right about "many factors" and expecting the same "exact" sound... but, he will get closer to copying that Mayes/C4 sound clip with the same gear than he would trying to copy it without using the same gear.
Oh I agree... however, if you've ever been hired as a session musician who is expected to get a sound that is being required, you'd know that in order to do so one must begin with the required playing style and equipment/gear. For example... after you know how to play the song like Jimi Hendrix if you really want to copy the sound of Jimi you'd also use a strat (upsidedown) and Marshall... rather than a Les Paul and Boogie. PS... eli's guitar work on the Mayes/C4 sound clip is good... not hard to play... it's more like a little fun noodling thing... but I like it. Anyway, the point is... if someone wanted to copy that Mayes/C4 sound clip they would also need a PA-2.alanhyatt said:Again, this is an assumption. You would then need to buy John's guitars, and they are expensive. They are also very good, but they are expensive. Then, you would need to go to the same location and room where the recording took place, ask for the same weather conditions, and more.
Not to start anything here, but the same gear is not going to get someone closer to that sound. This is where hard realization has to come into play. Good recordings can be all luck, or all skill, but too many other variables come into play to make that assumption, and that is why buying the same gear is not the answer.
Buying John's guitars to get an incredible guitar is one thing, but playing it with the correct fingering also adds to the tone of the guitar. John had a very good player to work with. So while this is one post I think you had something positive to add, your assumption in my opinion would still not acheive the same results, or perhaps anyway near it.
True story:DJL said:Oh I agree... however, if you've ever been hired as a session musician who is expected to get a sound that is being required, you'd know that in order to do so one must begin with the required playing style and equipment/gear. For example... after you know how to play the song like Jimi Hendrix if you really want to copy the sound of Jimi you'd also use a strat (upsidedown) and Marshall... rather than a Les Paul and Boogie.
DJL said:Oh I agree... not hard to play... it's more like a little fun noodling thing... but I like it. Anyway, the point is... if someone wanted to copy that Mayes/C4 sound clip they would also need a PA-2.
PS... did John Mayes use the older type of C4's (before the Brent Casey C4 Mod's) or were they the newer C4 mic used for that Mayes/C4 sound clip?
Harvey Gerst said:True story:
It ain't the gear; it never was.
It never will be.
Yeah, it's sweet, unless you happen to be (or think you are) a guitar player. Then you realize just how far you still hafta go. That's been the story of my life; I've hung around with some of the best guitar players on the planet (Clapton, Zappa, Albert King, Merle Travis, Rosmini, Rick Ruskin, etc.), all willing to show me anything I wanted to know. And it only made me realize just how much I would never be able to play.John Mayes said:AWESOME story! Man that would have been sweet to meet Jimi.