Great Post
Ed,
I gotta hand it to ya, this post was even more thorough and well-thought out than you have ever been (IMO). This post put you in another dimension of engineering. Now there's talk of you publishing.....
One thing I'd like to interject to the entire group. I realize that there's a lot of "rockers" (as in guitars, amps, electric bass, drums and vocals). I think that's very cool. But at risk of offending some on this site, I think that many folks should get REal when it comes to accepting the reality and viability of sythesizer-oriented music styles such as pop, R&B, rap and other "electronic" music styles. Sure it may not be as fun to "engineer", because you're mostly dealing with sound from keyboard/sampler to preamp to recorder (as opposed to micing amps and such). Basically quality keyboard/sampler sounds, a good mic pre and good cable are all that counts.
Believe it or not, there are many people all over this world that actually enjoy music EVen if it doesn't have a hint of a guitar in it (not to take anything from guitar-oriented music). So while Madonna, Backstreet, Kirk Franklin or Jay Z's music may not move you, I suggest language that includes synth-driven music and doesn't look down upon it (engineering-wise). Because when it comes down to it, Tha' PEople buy it all, and probably will continue to do so whether you think it's real engineering or not.
Rev E