Notice a lot of unfair Behringer bashing, what's up?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jeff0633
  • Start date Start date
Blue Bear Sound said:
GO AHEAD - buy Behringer or other budget gear if/when it works for you....

Assuming you keep improving your recording skills, your ears will tell you when it's time to invest in better gear anyways.........

The fact that you lump the sound of a Great River pre in with the sound of a Behringer mixer means your ears aren't quite there yet!

I agree totally. If you didn't listen to the songs in my first post, then you should. In my case, the song done on the Behringer stuff, in a decent room, is way better than the song done on a Great River in a shitty room. My entire purpose here was to show that in actuality, a good room will probably make a much bigger difference when upgrading compared to upgrading from a Mackie pre to a Great River. Of course, the Great River would have improved the song done in the decent room even more, but the change would not be as dramatic as the difference between a decent room, and a shitty one with reflections going everywhere, and muddy bass frequencies. The post was clear, and really, no one has said anything that I disagree with as far as the room and pres. The only thing I have disagreed with is that there is some moral obligation not to buy Behringer products that are being legally sold in my country, and I have disagreed with the notion that it is impossible to make a good recording with Behringer equipment. Take a UB series Mixer, with a behringer B-2 condenser, with a Behringer new model Composer, with a New model Virtualizer, into a fine, state of the art recording room, and a recording can be made that would absolutely please just about any home-recordist out there that is trying to record in their bedroom. That's my point, and I stand buy it. I think much of the problem here is that many of the posters here are not home-recordist, like the forum was originally about, and has turned in to the semi-pro recordist with thousands of dollars to spend. The point I am making here is that these kind of guys already expect you to be recording in a well tuned recording space. many of them might be so used to having agreat space for so long that it doesn't even pop into their minds anymore when they are giving a true home-recordist advice. I would think that one of the first questions a pro would ask a newbie home recordist when he says his recording don't sound "Pro" is, "hey, what kind of space are you recording in"? If I tell you to go out and spend a grand on a Mic pre, but yet you are sitting in a fucking mobile home with traffic outside, no sound absorption on your walls, no bass traps and open corners on all four walls, you aren't going to find that a thousand dollar pre is going to give you much satisfaction. That is what I was trying to point out. Higher is this thread, someone made a reply that the Spirit boards were good, and that if I had a thousand to 2 thousand for a mid-level project studio. I would think that since the name of this chat board has the words home recording in them, most of the folks here would like to spend 300 on a mixer, not two grand. These people need to know that yes, they can make recordings that would absolutely thrill 95 percent of every bedroom-recordist out there, and that they can use a Behringer preamp, with a Behringer composer, and a Behringer B-2 condenser, with a Behringer effects. But if they are recording in a shitty room, then spending a grand on a mixer or two channel pre is going to do very little for them, until they take care of the recording environment they are in first. I think the two songs that I gave links to show this quite clear. I was simply trying to help keep some of the newbie home-recordist out there from burying themselves in debt by buying a pre that cost a grand, and then finding out that they are still unsatisfied by what they are recording. This happened to me, and I still am paying for the great River, even though I sold it and bought a Peavey VMP2 with the money. I am still unsatisfied with my recordings, and I can't afford to spend two grand now on good 3 and 4 inch studio foam, with really nice bass traps and cieling treatments. I wish I would have had someone tell me to do that first, instead of telling me to upgrade my Behringer preamps up to a Great river. had they, I would probably have a great recording space right now, and maybe be ready to invest in an RNP. So, really, I don't even disagree with you in any way.

Have a good one.

Jeff
 
chessrock said:
You mean to tell me that if you saw a dead kitten being sold at your nearest Guitar Center or Sam Ash store . . . sitting between the Microphone cord isle and the keyboard section . . .

with a big, fat price tag around it's dead little neck . . .

. . . that you wouldn't find it in the least bit strange?

See, that's the problem with you. You just figure "hey, the cat is sitting there, and they're selling it at a public joint . . . it must be normal."

You're a sick puppy.

Dude, you are way off with this analogy. My response was very clear, and you didn't actually reply to anything specific.

Tell me, when you go to the Grocery store, and see a big fat ham laying there between the Cheese and the Milk, you wouldn't find it the elast bit strange? They might in India? get the point? Your analogy simply doesn't hold. Cruelty to animals in illegal in this country. I am not sure about selling deat cats for medical purposes or something. The point is, if my music store is DOING SOMETHING ILLEGAL, and I find out about it, then I would not buy from them. My music store would not be selling dead cats, for they have no reason to. IF THEY DID HAVE A REASON TO, THEN SO WOULD OTHER MUSIC STORES, WHICH WOULD MEAN THAT MUSICIANS, FOR SOME REASON, ARE BUYING DEAD KITTENS. If I happened to need dead kittens, like many other musicians, then i would have no problem buy dead kittens from any certain company, as long as they were doing things in a legal manner. If they were killing kittens in some wrong manner, and the law found them guilty, then they would not be able to sell their kittens anymore, GET IT? You analogy was kind of childish, actually, though I don't mean to start a flame war with you. If you have something with substance to it, then I would be glad to discus it with you. Jeff
 
jeff0633 said:
Well, I have my flame suit on, so let's hear your comments.


Hey Jeffy! Better check that flamesuit.

Ha ha. Gotcha ! ! ! :D :D

I was just toyin' with ya about the kittens. Sorry if I pushed one of your buttons, there guy. I was just putting your flame suit through a little quality control test. Again, I'm sorry. he he.

However, I do think it's kind of shallow of someone to care only about the letter of the law with no regard to the spirit of the law. Certainly, there's a difference between something being illegal, and something being immoral or going against ones' personal ethics. There's nothing illegal about screwing your best friend's girlfriend, for example, but that doesn't make it right.

Obviously, you figure "as long as it's legal, it's okay." And I guess that's not necessarily a bad thing . . . if all you care about is maintaining the arguably low status quo our society seems to be content adhering to.

It might be a bit naive to just assume that all of the judges and lawyers out there are all doing their jobs, and that if there was something questionable going on somewhere, then the situation would have been dealt with accordingly. Maybe in a perfect world.
 
So this isn't actually a 'Behringer gear is good thread' it is yet another 'the music and talent is more important then the gear' thread.

Well, no shit.
 
Re: Re: Notice a lot of unfair Behringer bashing, what's up?

chessrock said:
Hey Jeffy! Better check that flamesuit.

Ha ha. Gotcha ! ! ! :D :D

Damn, I should have known. I'll patch the holes in the flame suit.



I was just toyin' with ya about the kittens. Sorry if I pushed one of your buttons, there guy. I was just putting your flame suit through a little quality control test. Again, I'm sorry. he he.

However, I do think it's kind of shallow of someone to care only about the letter of the law with no regard to the spirit of the law. Certainly, there's a difference between something being illegal, and something being immoral or going against ones' personal ethics. There's nothing illegal about screwing your best friend's girlfriend, for example, but that doesn't make it right.


I agree, but that would be a shitty move toward me. I deal with my music store, and I see no reason to go above their heads on a crusade. I trust them as I trust a best friend. If they fuck me, (or my girl friend", then they can say goodbye to my business. Other than that, I have no reason to go above the head of my music store and question where they get products for me to check out and buy. What I am saying is, when my music store buys a product, then to me, that product becomes theirs. When I buy it, then I am buying from my music store, not from someone else. If I were to start crusading by looking for wrong business practices, I would have to be searching for 20 hours a day. I believe I am following the spirit of the law. It's not my place to judge them as doing something wrong when the courts say they haven't, and allow their products to be sold.



Obviously, you figure "as long as it's legal, it's okay." And I guess that's not necessarily a bad thing . . . if all you care about is maintaining the arguably low status quo our society seems to be content adhering to.

I don't know, I think it's a high ideal to trust our legal system. I just can't see any moral reason to go above my music store's head and start asking questions about the companies they buy their stock from. When I purchased my UB mixer, my music store had already purchased it, so I purchased it from them, not Behringer.


It might be a bit naive to just assume that all of the judges and lawyers out there are all doing their jobs, and that if there was something questionable going on somewhere, then the situation would have been dealt with accordingly. Maybe in a perfect world.

I see your point, but it also would be a hassle to try and go looking for companies that are engaging in bad business practices. I couldn't possibly sit in a courtroom and hear the evidence and legal arguments of what Behringer has done. If I can't possible know ALL the facts, then I am not going to crusade against them. To me, that would be unjust. At some point, you have to just accept that your music store is the entity responsible to you for the products they offer you, and let all the other folks in society do their jobs. No crusades for me unless I am sitting in every court room every day getting all the facts.

Have a good one.

Jeff
 
Now I know more than I want to.

I just bought a berringer EQ, works just fine but dont know much about the company.
I'll deffinitely go back to the tried and true brands but I'm not rich. I'd definitely like black widows better than dead kittens anyday.
 
Re: Re: Re: Notice a lot of unfair Behringer bashing, what's up?

jeff0633 said:
No crusades for me unless I am sitting in every court room every day getting all the facts.


I suppose that's admirable.

Just for shits and giggles, I'll give you a hypothetical scenario: For a while, there, Ephedrine was a legal substance and was sold at many reputable stores. Subsequent tests have shown it to be quite unsafe, and is now a banned narcotic. Do you still trust your drug stores to sell only safe and healthy diet supplements?
 
chessrock said:
If the store you bought from started selling dead kittens, but you knew it was legal to do so . . . would you still think that selling dead kittens is right? The beauty of the free market is that we can vote for what we feel is right or wrong with our pocket book. When you buy Behringer, you're basically giving your support to their business practices and saying you agree with them in not so many words. And your dollars help them to continue such practices -- ethical or not.


And if you , say, charge people to record in your studio under the pretences that you are *just as good* as other pro studios, without actually *being* a pro studio with pro equipment and suitable experience, you would be practicing unethical buisiness practices too, No?

Those dollars spent on your studio take away the buisiness from the *real* pros who would, no doubt, do a finer job of recording your project.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Notice a lot of unfair Behringer bashing, what's up?

chessrock said:
I suppose that's admirable.

Just for shits and giggles, I'll give you a hypothetical scenario: For a while, there, Ephedrine was a legal substance and was sold at many reputable stores. Subsequent tests have shown it to be quite unsafe, and is now a banned narcotic. Do you still trust your drug stores to sell only safe and healthy diet supplements?

I trust my drug store to follow the law. When it became illegal, the product was discontinued. We trusted the folks with the job to find out if it was healthy or not, and they did there job, and the product was stopped. My drug store sold it, following the law, and when they knew it was bad, they no longer offred it, and would be able to get any of it. So, my drug store is off the hook. Your trying to show guilt by simple association, and I can't go for that. If my drug store follows the laws, then that's as much as I expect from them.

Jeff
 
Behringer gear can kiss my ENTIRE black @ss!!!

'Nuff said!:mad:
 
Gimme a break...

I'm really sick of this whole "morally correct" bullshit. Let he who hath never sinned throw the first stone.

Hands up all of us here here who do not own ANY product (clothes, furniture, electrical goods, toys, etc, etc) that was made in China, purely because we don't want to support a communist regime which supports child/slave labour. Any takers?

If you like Behringer, buy their products.

Or don't.

'nuff said...

Dingo
 
acorec said:
And if you , say, charge people to record in your studio under the pretences that you are *just as good* as other pro studios, without actually *being* a pro studio with pro equipment and suitable experience, you would be practicing unethical buisiness practices too, No?

If that were the case, in a hypothetical scenario, then you would be correct.

However, since this is not the case and doesn't actually apply, it isn't relevent.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Notice a lot of unfair Behringer bashing, what's up?

chessrock said:
For a while, there, Ephedrine was a legal substance and was sold at many reputable stores. Subsequent tests have shown it to be quite unsafe, and is now a banned narcotic. Do you still trust your drug stores to sell only safe and healthy diet supplements?
Just to clarify:
1) Ephedrine is not a narcotic - it is a sympathomimetic
2) It is not banned - it is still a prescription drug - and will only be banned as a dietary supplement (ephedrine, ephedra, ma huang) - and is still availble. The ban is not effective until early April.
http://www.fda.gov/bbs/topics/NEWS/2004/NEW01021.html

I think stores will sell you anything that's legal and makes them money - it's not their responsibility to guarantee the safety of their products. Aspirin and Tylenol can kill you too.

And I think that people will buy the cheapest product available that fits their needs, no matter who makes it or where it's made. If a gasoline company named "Osama's 9/11" were to sell gas for 50 cents a gallon under the going rate, people would flock to it (though probably in the dark and wearing a disguise.:))
 
Re: Re: Re: Notice a lot of unfair Behringer bashing, what's up?

jeff0633 said:
I see your point, but it also would be a hassle to try and go looking for companies that are engaging in bad business practices. I couldn't possibly sit in a courtroom and hear the evidence and legal arguments of what Behringer has done. If I can't possible know ALL the facts, then I am not going to crusade against them. To me, that would be unjust. At some point, you have to just accept that your music store is the entity responsible to you for the products they offer you, and let all the other folks in society do their jobs. No crusades for me unless I am sitting in every court room every day getting all the facts.

Have a good one.

Jeff

What a fuckin flake you turned out to be.

"The music store is responsible.............":rolleyes:

Blow it out your punk ass.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Notice a lot of unfair Behringer bashing, what's up?

c7sus said:
What a fuckin flake you turned out to be.

"The music store is responsible.............":rolleyes:

Blow it out your punk ass.


:D :D :D
 
Re: Gimme a break...

Sir Dingo said:
I'm really sick of this whole "morally correct" bullshit. Let he who hath never sinned throw the first stone.

Hands up all of us here here who do not own ANY product (clothes, furniture, electrical goods, toys, etc, etc) that was made in China, purely because we don't want to support a communist regime which supports child/slave labour. Any takers?

The real argument isn't whether it's made in China or not, as it's quite legal to have products made in China. Of course most or all of us own products made in China. The real argument is regarding Behringer's theft of designs from other manufacturers. No reasonable person can justify that.
 
Oh...I see....

We can't support one comapny copying a product from another company....but we can support a communist regime and it's evil practices buy buying products manufactured there?

Is that what a "reasonable person can justify"? Supporting child slave labour is fine and totally justified, but companies making a cheaper copy of a product is worse than the devil himself???

That's my whole point poeple. It's the pot calling the kettle black.

If people are going to slam Behringer for being "morally wrong" and "copying" products, then we must be fair and slam ALL companies that are "morally wrong" because they have their products made in China, Indonesia, etc (Studio Projects, NIKE, Behringer, MXL, etc, etc).

Gimme a break...
 
I got some behringer units in my racks, and they work fine. With that said, it's nothing that I would consider using on a lead vocal or something.

But they're good as extra units to use on some channels that sits deeper in the mix, when all other units are busy and you need that extra compressor.

I never had a Behringer unit malfunction or break down on me, and I bought my first maybe 10 years ago. However, I'm replacing them anyway, maybe one of the ones I've sold has broken down by now.

Heres the pieces I own and occasionally use.

Composer ( my first compressor, not good but better than the 3630)
Multiband denoiser (great unit actually)
Headphone amp (great unit)
Patchbays (been replacing them lately, after a friend had trouble with his, but they worked fine for me so far)
ECM8000 (great mics, especially considering the price tag)

I wouldn't recommend their consoles though.
 
hmm.....now this has got me to thinking. Where does our local Peking restaurant get its dead cats?
 
Where does Behringer get those dead cats?
In His Name
BK
 
Back
Top