jjtcorsair said:
The longer I take to write them the better they are. The longer I take to record them the better they sound. But damn if I don't hate them by the time I'm done.
For me, thats a bad barometer of my song. Hopefully, different scenario for you. The really good ones keep inspiring me even after they are done. If my foot keeps tapping and I'm getting pulled in by the thing, thats when I know I have something. If I get 3/4 of the way done and its giving me a bad attitute, it goes in the garbage and I start another one.
This is not to be confused with the numbing factor of hearing the same thing 100 times in a row. Listen to the same thing too long and you can't hear it anymore. Best then to get a break and come back fresh.
As for this whole time factor, all that matters is if you get something good. Elton John used to allow only 30 minutes to write a tune. If it didn't happen, he would move on to something else.
For me, musical ideas are often pretty easy because its feeling and inspiration. Lyrics are another thing. Lyrics are sacred ground. I need to have something to say--a subject--a theme--a genuine idea that makes the whole process that follows worth the time. I've benn guilty as hell of falling short of those ideals, but the hunger to rise above mediocrity still burns in my soul. I like those songs where you know somebody was home when they were written.
I don't know what place there is for the soul of a poet in this musical landscape we are faced with today. Sometimes I think that the whole idea of music as disposable entertainment has sifted into the minds of lyricists and they whip off whatever fits the meter of the tune. End of story. For me, that doesn't hold water for very long. How many songs can you hear that are like that before you just get bored because you're hearing nothing, really? Great sounding records are neat to hear, but after the production values, what if they aren't saying anything relevant? Whats the difference between that and Brittany Spears? Not much.
I better get outta here. I'm getting frustrated again...