The Hot Rod series is kinda lame. I used one for a year and was never happy with it.
Check out Peavey's Classic series. Classic 30/50/Delta Blues etc....
Much better sound and feel in my opinion.
You know, I'd be the very last to put down Peavey, as I had both a Classic 30 and a Delta Blues 410, until recently. Sold the C30 after buying the DB210 because they were just too much alike, and then sold
the DB210 after buying a Silverface Twin Reverb (then trading it straight across for a Deluxe Reverb) because the Fenders had a noticably better tone. Again, not raggin' on the Peaveys, just I got lucky and could thus move forward. I now have a silverface Pro Reverb, in addition to the Deluxe Reverb. My comparison impressions:
All 3 Fenders (which are from the late 70's) have better tone than the Peaveys. You would only really hear it in a studio environment, though- live, I don't think anyone would notice. Dunno how modern Fenders would compare.
The Tremomo (Fender has always, lamely and incorrectly, called it vibrato) on the Fenders is deeper than the Peaveys- but again, it's SO deep that you would rarely ever need that much trem depth. I know the amps you are looking at do not have tremolo- but you can turn it off easily!
Reverb on both F's and P's is way deep- all have much more than any sane man could ever want or need.
The Fenders DO turn heads more than the Peaveys did, if that's important to you. It is to some, if only because it sorta gives you cred. Of course, you can just remove the Peavey badge from the front of slightly older C30's and C50's, and only the really sharp-eyed will notice.
I am not a touring musician on a budget. On a budget, yes, but I bought these right and almost can not lose money on them. I understand the Peaveys are very popular among touring musicians, and I can tell you that Peavey's customer service runs RINGS around Fender's- something that would be very important if you find yourself on the road and your amp craps out, or even if it gets beat up.
As for your original question, I can not address it directly from personal experience, but I can offer this: The guy who traded his Deluxe for my Twin did so because he was getting lost next to the drummer. He later told me the Twin (late 70's 125-watt model) had MORE than enough, and could spank his drummer if he wanted to. 'Course, he went from 20 watts to 125. My Pro has 60 watts (as I recall) and two 12's, and was plenty loud up against a drummer, and 6 other musicians, last Friday.
Oh, the Pro is for sale, too. Competative to the amps you are considering. PM or email me if interested.