Drum samples and digital clipping??

  • Thread starter Thread starter DavidK
  • Start date Start date
crosstudio said:
DavidK what software are you using?

I am using Sonar 3. Hearing distortion is quite easy on a piano patch or violins. Keep in mind that I do not record too hot, it is merely the after-processing that I was referring to.
 
unless you've got an automatic brick-wall limiter at 0 somewhere in the audio chain, even those drum transients will cause the nasty digital crackles.

but cutting off drum transients and distortion are two different things.

i think the clip setting use to be in options-->audio-->advanced but i can't remember which version of Sonar that was.
 
crosstudio said:
but cutting off drum transients and distortion are two different things.
Sorry, my teminology was incorrect. :o I think of everything above 0 db as distortion, and I guess that is not the accurate term. :confused: Anyhoo, I went back and used the version that is 100% safe.

There is a lot to learn about perceived loudness and actual loudness I reckon. The whole "loudness war" eludes me as a classical musician, we try so hard to have a massive dynamic range. My foray into Rock-ish music makes me want to have everything as loud as possible, much to my vexation at times. ;)
 
DavidK said:
I also know that rules are made to be broken, and ultimately how it sounds is what matters.

some rules....not all rules especially in recording
 
scorpio01169 said:
some rules....not all rules especially in recording
Of course. If I was convinced that something sounded better and/or was musically appropriate, I would simply do it. In this case, it is not better or worse, therefore I will be neat and tidy. :)
 
I have clipped my mix at mastering stage in Wavelab and had good results.
I would limit the mix after clipping it though.

Eck
 
ecktronic said:
I have clipped my mix at mastering stage in Wavelab and had good results.
I would limit the mix after clipping it though.
You are limiting the mix by clipping it. What does the extra limiter do?
 
Farview said:
I've worked with Black Sabbath, Bon Jovi, skid Row, Manowar, etc...

when working with manowar did you listen on monitors made of fire and steel, mix on a board made from the bones of wimps and posers, or use any cables forged with true metal? Also, did at any time, anyone 'leave the hall' by request of the artists or recording staff?


seriously though, manowar rules!
 
TerraMortim said:
when working with manowar did you listen on monitors made of fire and steel, mix on a board made from the bones of wimps and posers,
John Tesh does that stuff. :rolleyes: :D
 
Farview said:
You are limiting the mix by clipping it. What does the extra limiter do?
Im not limiting by clipping.
Clipping brings up the volume but too much will cause distortion.
Limiting after clipping stops the signal going past 0dB.
If you dont limit then some sound systems could get damaged or exagerate the stuff above 0dB.

Eck
 
ecktronic said:
If you dont limit then some sound systems could get damaged or exagerate the stuff above 0dB.

Eck
Really??? :confused:

I have to learn a lot more about this, my knowledge is really not up to where it should be. :o
 
ecktronic said:
Im not limiting by clipping.
Yes, you are.
ecktronic said:
Clipping brings up the volume but too much will cause distortion.
Limiting after clipping stops the signal going past 0dB.
The signal can't go past 0dbfs. It does in wavelab at 32 bit float. But as soon as you dither down to a non-floating bit depth, everything above 0dbfs disappears. This happens at the converters and when you render the file to 24 or 16 bit.
ecktronic said:
If you dont limit then some sound systems could get damaged or exagerate the stuff above 0dB.
Like I said before, there is no way to play a digital signal above 0dbfs on any system anywhere.
 
DavidK said:
Really??? :confused:

I have to learn a lot more about this, my knowledge is really not up to where it should be. :o
No, this isn't the way it works.
 
ecktronic said:
Im not limiting by clipping.
Clipping brings up the volume but too much will cause distortion.
Limiting after clipping stops the signal going past 0dB.
If you dont limit then some sound systems could get damaged or exagerate the stuff above 0dB.

Eck

Gotta agree with Farview here. You really have a lot of stuff wrong.

A brick wall limiter will pretty much just flat line everything that goes above it's "brick wall" limit. Usually, you would have a comprerssor in front of it to get 99.9 % or better of the signal from going thru to the brick wall - the L2 has both. When a signal trys to go above 0, it just flatlines at zero - this is clipping, and is pretty much the same as a brick wall limiter. It cannot go above zero (except in a 32 bit float enviroment - sorda)
 
come on fairview...tell me? did they play on ten, did speakers explode? did they ride their metal steeds of steel into the control room? I must know!

;)
 
I stand corrected.
When I rendered to 16bit the peaks went away. :)

Eck
 
TerraMortim said:
come on fairview...tell me? did they play on ten, did speakers explode? did they ride their metal steeds of steel into the control room? I must know!

;)
A speaker in the bass cabinet started on fire. They drove rented cars. It was winter in chicago.
 
sweet. So they drove thier horseless carriges of fire and steel. hehehehe what album were you working on?
 
TerraMortim said:
sweet. So they drove thier horseless carriges of fire and steel. hehehehe what album were you working on?
Hell on wheels. No, they were no re-recording tracks on a live album. The bass cabinet blew up on the tour. The tour is where the metal steeds of steel and the leather, fire, blackwind, etc... comes in to play.

Right now I'm producing their former guitarist's (David Shankle) new album.

BTW. It's Farview, not fairview. A true brother of metal would know that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NL5
Farview said:
Hell on wheels. No, they were no re-recording tracks on a live album. The bass cabinet blew up on the tour. The tour is where the metal steeds of steel and the leather, fire, blackwind, etc... comes in to play.

Right now I'm producing their former guitarist's (David Shankle) new album.

BTW. It's Farview, not fairview. A true brother of metal would know that.


hehehe I know just playing with you. I do like Manowar tho. Cool, hows the album coming along? what type of music is it?
 
Back
Top