Tucci..
Tucci,
You said,
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>1. The music itself is often indistinguishable from the over-produced, over hyped, and over commercialized pop/rock garbage that you hear on top 40 radio. The lyrics are the only thing that make it christian and these often are extremely sappy and insipid.
2. Sometimes the music is outstanding and original and sometimes the lyrics are too;
BUT - Christian/pop, Christian/rock, Christian/Metal, Christian/Punk, Christian/rap, etc. All have one basic problem that I see and that is:
The beauty, truth, and importance of the divine message they are trying to convey is subverted by the music that accompanies it. The music itself should support and augment the meaning of the lyrics. It is absolutely ludicrous and oxymoronic to scream "christian" lyrics into a microphone with a Sex-Pistol style of music for background.
I heard some Christian Punk the other day that I honestly would not have known was christian if the person playing the cd hadn't told me. For all I could tell the vocalist was shouting profanities(indeed, the sound of his voice suggested that was what he was doing).
Christian/pop/alternative rock etc. is just as bad. A pop/rock love song should stay a pop/rock sappy love song. This kind of music has a place. A good old rock'n'roll tune about a car and a cute girl has its place and is very enjoyable.
To insert christian-based lyrics into these styles degrades the message itself and ruins the pop love song or rock'n'roll tune by trying to make them into something they're not. It's like trying to turn your kitchen sink into a jacuzzi. The sink was never meant to be a jacuzzi and won't turn into one no matter what you do to it. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
I write Christian music,
http://www.mp3.com/gbat , and I appreciate your viewpoint. I think it is good for us to hear this kind of logical thinking, us who write this kind of music. I hope my music conveys the feeling of the lyrics and is not just an attempt to "make Jesus fit in". He doesn't need to be hyped as "cool". Yet I wonder if it is not pleasing to Him when people express His love in their own way. I don't know, I guess only He knows our real motivations.
I must admit I get a bit sick sometimes when I hear the material that comes out of our local Christian station. I'd rather listen to an old uncouth country preacher, or some down home folks singing from their hearts, or some hymns. I hate slick productions in which the performers are full of themselves and convey no sence of sincerity.
I shall print your words and use them as inspiration. Thank you.