Yo vsimmons- sorry for misunderstanding your slang- all due apologies. We do really get some jerks on the board who are proud of their crimes.
Malcolm- what do you whip out a badass mic for? Almost anything. Those of us who are lucky enough to own a badass mic or 2 usually only own 1 or 2, so you have to look for versatility. I only own one really high end mic (B.L.U.E. Kiwi), and I intend to add another soon (probably Lawson L251 or Soundelux U99). Generally, if I'm mic'ing just one track, I pull out the best mic I have, and if I don't like what I hear, I try less expensive mics. A kickass project studio is an unholy alliance of cheap gear that works and a few pieces of truly top flight gear.
I use an Avalon AD2022, and it works for me. I also use a Joemeek twinQcs and a DMP-3. One thing I can say about the Avalon- when the sound sucks, it's not because my preamp sucks. It usually means I have the wrong mic in the wrong place.
And Littledog's right- it has commercial appeal. Not just that the customer demands it, but when I brought in an engineer to assist with some mic placement (I'm hearing disabled), he asked, "what are you using for mics and pres?" I said, "Well,
the gold channel is a B.L.U.E. Kiwi into an Avalon AD2022." And he says, "So, you don't have a problem, right?"
When you drive up in a Rolls Royce limo, they may not like your car, they may say it was too expensove, it may be they prefer the Ferrari, but they don't ask why you didn't buy a luxury car.
Finally, aside from the usually superior sound created by superior gear, there is a psychological effect on the musician. If you put a piece of pantyhose stretched over an embroidery hoop in front of an SM57, the singer is going to produce garage band sound, because that's where his head is. If you put a Stedman or a Sabrasom in front of a Neumann, he's going to produce big time studio sound, because he thinks he's in a real studio. Often people rise to the level of their surroundings.-Richie