i'll tell you this.......
my experiments and experience started back in '75......
when i had
a fender mustang, and the single coil pickups in it sounded really good, but were quite noisy.....
then, i upgraded to a really fine Ibanez Artist, and that was during my search for the perfect LES PAUL !!
LOL
the ibanez won......
anyway, it had humbuckers, that were voiced just so nice.....
and a phase switch that had a really spanking sound......
but i still didn't have exactly the tone that i heard in my head.....
so i searched again........
ended up with a Carvin.
now, the carvin guitar itself was awesome, but the pickups were not.
a good sound, reminiscent of a PAF, but microphonic as hell......
and that's when i started with all the different pickups......
all the hot duncans at the time (1982-1985).......
all the dimarzios......
i'd say i went through 4 duncans, and 3 dimarzios.....
and since then, i've a/b'd just about every new thing on the wall....
all the new gibson pickups in the better pauls....
the newer fender vintage series, the lace pickups, all that.....
back in 1986, i had a custom axe built, and since i couldn't find a passive pickup that i REALLY liked, i put in
EMG SA's.......
3 active single coils, with a presence knob.......
thought that was the deal for a while, a really good clean sound.....
til i realized that the active electronics just would not react the way i wanted them to through the front end of my mesa boogie.......
ultimately, i ended up with the bill Lawrence L-280s, in place of the EMG's.......
the most musical pickups i've found to date.
there are still a lot of pickups out there i haven't tried........
and i bet they kick ass........
but i don't know if they'd only cost $40.
like the lawrence did.