Thrust,I have been using the Mackie 32x8 since 2001 and have never had a problem with it yet.It has served me well and I have no negative comments on this product,...maybe I got lucky with mine.I also have no disapointments concerning sound quality of the console.I have used this console with both the MSR-24,Tascam DA-78's and Protools with satisfactory results.However,as we both are aware,...analog and digital recordings during playback are going to sound very different through the same board,...so while they both sound good I and many others still prefer the analog mix.I just think sometimes that it is an innate feature within us humans to gravitate towards the more natural sounding analog sound reproduction.
I have conducted several A/B type tests on several clients by having them listen to an analog and digital mix of their recordings.I would say that 98 percent of the time the listener has chosen the analog mix over the digital one.The only digital recorder that nails the analog sound in my opinion is the RADAR-24 by iZ Technology.You have to hear it to believe it!,..one will be hard pressed to not pick it as the 2" analog recording,...it's that good.
Also,I have been considering purchasing and replacing the Mackie with either the TL Audio VTC 32 channel tube console or the Toft Audio Designs ATB32 and retiring the Mackie.Will also be investing in the RADAR-24 in the future to complete the one-two punch for that creamy PHAT heavenly analog sound.
Cheers