
Lt. Bob
Spread the Daf!
Re: Part 2
I agree with Macle....there is no universal mysterious cosmic/biological unseen force that makes a human being emote over certain sounds. One easy to see example is western versus eastern music. Hell....the 12-tone scale we use isn't even the way nature breaks down the notes. Technically, for instance C# and Db aren't even the same note. They're very close together but if you break it down mathmatically....they are two different notes which we have compromised into being one note. Actually....J.S. Bach did this when he came up with the concept of even-tempered tuning. So how can a TOTALLY man-made and created thing have deep biologic responses? They are, instead, emotional responses that are affected greatly by ones culture and personality and as such.....will vary from individual to individual.
Now I'm not saying you don't have a point......but I still don't see how you can say that virtually anyone will recognise a 'wildcard'. You gave yourself and your daughter as an example.....hardly a representitive sample of the public. You, and your daughter I'm sure, have a much wider taste and appreciation for music than normal folks and you simply don't count when we're talking about the masses. And when you talk about the masses loving and buying a certain album.....I'd bet the house that we're actually talking about the masses who like that particular type of music. Like it or not......the masses that buy Hole and Perfect Circle are not gonna recognise a country hit no matter what 'cause they hate it and I garuntee....put on a country tune and they're either laughing or rolling their eyes or retching. It all depends on what you mean when you say 'the masses'. If you want to stipulate that we mean the people who like a certain type of music, then I'm on board but if you mean the whole of humanity.....then I simply don't agree and that is also based on just as many years in the biz as you have.
I agree with Macle....there is no universal mysterious cosmic/biological unseen force that makes a human being emote over certain sounds. One easy to see example is western versus eastern music. Hell....the 12-tone scale we use isn't even the way nature breaks down the notes. Technically, for instance C# and Db aren't even the same note. They're very close together but if you break it down mathmatically....they are two different notes which we have compromised into being one note. Actually....J.S. Bach did this when he came up with the concept of even-tempered tuning. So how can a TOTALLY man-made and created thing have deep biologic responses? They are, instead, emotional responses that are affected greatly by ones culture and personality and as such.....will vary from individual to individual.
And a quick point......I'm not wrong....you just don't agree. There is a difference you know and unless your claiming that your opinion is the defining one and therefore anyone who disagrees with you is wrong, I don't really appreciate the blanket statement that I am wrong as if I don't have any knowledge of this buisiness. I'll put my experience up against yours too.crawdad said:Getting back to an earlier post of Lt. Bob's, I must say--Steve--you're wrong,
Now I'm not saying you don't have a point......but I still don't see how you can say that virtually anyone will recognise a 'wildcard'. You gave yourself and your daughter as an example.....hardly a representitive sample of the public. You, and your daughter I'm sure, have a much wider taste and appreciation for music than normal folks and you simply don't count when we're talking about the masses. And when you talk about the masses loving and buying a certain album.....I'd bet the house that we're actually talking about the masses who like that particular type of music. Like it or not......the masses that buy Hole and Perfect Circle are not gonna recognise a country hit no matter what 'cause they hate it and I garuntee....put on a country tune and they're either laughing or rolling their eyes or retching. It all depends on what you mean when you say 'the masses'. If you want to stipulate that we mean the people who like a certain type of music, then I'm on board but if you mean the whole of humanity.....then I simply don't agree and that is also based on just as many years in the biz as you have.