DM60
Well-known member
To each his own, and there are obviously plenty of people who agree with you. Carry on
If you get everything correct in one take, then you are right. But usually when recording and when you are creating an original, that is not always as simple as is sounds. I don't think any disagrees with you, but there is this thing called reality, you are going to "F" it up. By separating the two, just makes it easier.
But yes, getting the perfect take with the vocals and guitar would be optimal approach.