
JimmyS1969
MOODerator
There is a huge difference between a room that is desirable to record in, and one you would want to mix in. I'm not sure I would go anywhere near 2/3 of the sound quality being dependent on the room, unless it was a 10' X 10' corrugated metal storage unit that the ratio was based in. In that situation, one might justify the extreme fraction in what is important to find good tone.
I would place 'well' treating a 'crappy' room at around 70% more benefit (mixing room), than a preamp at similar cost to treatment. It really just depends upon the particular room, and what gear is involved. I myself have found ways to find good tone (recoding) in 3' x 10' hallways. I sure as hell would not try to mix in that.
Apples and oranges.
BTW, I like oranges 2/3 more than apples.
I would place 'well' treating a 'crappy' room at around 70% more benefit (mixing room), than a preamp at similar cost to treatment. It really just depends upon the particular room, and what gear is involved. I myself have found ways to find good tone (recoding) in 3' x 10' hallways. I sure as hell would not try to mix in that.
Apples and oranges.
BTW, I like oranges 2/3 more than apples.