-6dB is a great place to *end up*, after everyone is settled in and in the groove. You can sneak it up a little as you go, tune to tune... I'd bet you started out at closer to -12 on the first tune, though. Poisoned your mind, I bet!
I just booked a date to do some one-take-wonder demo work for an *excellent* jazz quintet, right after Christmas. My wife and I are gonna set 'em up up in the living room here, so that they can use our acoustic piano. That and acoustic bass, tenor sax, 4-pc drums, and vocals. Live to multitrack, no overdubs, what you get is what you get... And then mix, compose, and burn a CD. 6 hour budget, load-in to load-out. They'll take however many tunes will fit. Whee!
Good news is that I already know how to mic my piano, and I know their style- so I can have all the mics selected, set up on stands, patched, the snake run down the stairs to the basement (which will just be a control room for this deal), the foldback speakers set up and levelchecked, and the board configured for tracking, with mic/channel/track assigns done, rough levels and pans dialed, and everything tested and ready before they arrive in the driveway. I'll have them mic'd up before they finish unpacking, and then it's time to track. The Christmas tree is just going to be an unusual acoustic treatment...
I learned early in my career that it's all about preparation. For those guys, I'll bet that the potato sack will only have 6-8dB in it as well, right from the start. They are true, seasoned pros, and know mic technique and studio discipline very well. They know their stuff _cold_, and now it's up to me to bring the same approach to the nerdy, knobtwisty parts of the date. This is gonna be just like old times!
This session is going to be a major hoot- I'll have to shoot some pictures, and get the rights to reuse some of the material. If I do, I'll post some here.