Speaking of all these mastering services, how do you guys feel about people recording at home, mixing at home, and sending the almost finished product to be mastered? Is it a decent, cheaper alternative ?
I personally have the greatest respect for the real, professional mastering services performed by John and the two Toms (and others of similar caliber), and heartily recommend them for any
serious project.
But I'm glad you phrased your question the way you have, because it brings up something that has always kind of bugged me about the thought process involved in the decision. Ask anybody who knows what they are actually talking about - including a good mastering engineer, BTW - and they will tell you how important it is to front-load the quality in any production; i.e. that you gotta start with a great performance and great tracking to even have a chance at a great mix, and that a great, *complete* mixing job is really what makes the mastering really shine.
Yet it is extremely rare around these parts to find artists who consider spending their budget on professional tracking or mixing, but quite common to find them willing to spend it on mastering.
The reason is they spend all their money on entry-to-mid-level gear at best, spend a year or so of their time just trying to learn how to use it (usually sacrificing actual practice of their music in the process), make a basic recording, phone in the mixing, and then realize their stuff just doesn't sound as good as the rest of their playlist, so they then have to fall on the mastering engineer to try and pull the rabbit out of the hat for them by - instead of actually mastering their project- having the mastering engineer try and fix all the problems they introduced by doing a dubious job of tracking and mixing.
Ya wanna do it right? Don't record until you're ready to record; there's no hurry to get something on meSapce before some deadline just because your buddy did already, and when you do do it, either take the time or the money to get it right out of the gate.
You can still decide how and who you want to master it when the time comes, and any *real* MEs will do (this does NOT mean some kid in a bedroom with a PC and a crack of Waves.) But don't wait until then to get it right.
G.