The reason I hate rap is not because it's roots are in the black community, or that many black people have become "famous" even though I consider them lesser musicians. It's because I appreciate music with a melody and an interesting harmonic structure.
I believe rap is ruining that (note the emphasis on I BELIEVE). I also believe that rap is dumbing down music, and I guess that is what I really have issues with - that and the fact that most practitioner's seem to be only interested in the music in order to get rich/famous quickly. Look at how many people are worried about copyrighting/publishing/ their work and getting a record deal long before they have developed any meaningful skills. It'as all about the business.
Don't get me wrong, there is a lot of crap in ANY genre. But to me, rap celebrates and embraces that which I despise. There may be one or two decent works, I dunno, I haven't heard them.
There is no arguing that certain rapper's lyrics are intersting. But that's what it is - poetry. It is not music to me.
Now, this is probably the first time I have mentioned that I don't like rap on this board- and that's because I don't believe I can speak for anyone else. BUT, whenever some moron comes along and says that "if you hate a genre you're an idiot", I take umbrage. I hate the genre because of what it musicially represents. It has NOTHING to do with race.
And I will tell you that hip/hop/rap is the ONLY genre that I feel this way about.
FWIW, I also do not believe a rap can be called a song. A song is SUNG, and it has a melody.
All this is of course, my opinion, and worth every cent you paid for it.
tone_aot said:
This is a crazy thread. It amazes me how people hate certain genres of music. I like to call myself an open minded music lover/musician. I'm not a diehard country fan, but i appreciate it as a different musical flavor. Seems like it would be boring to be stuck in one genre of music all your life. I admit, the "rap mic" threads are out of hand. Regardless, alot of people from all genres ask what is the best mic. So, all we have to do is direct them to the faq site everytime unless there is a specific need that they are looking for that is explained completely in their first post. Also i seen someone complain about repetitive tr808 sounds. That tells me that person bases rap on the commercial crap that is out now. Rap did start out with the tr808 but since then new sounds and styles have been implemented in the process of making rap instrumentals. When it's said and done, i appreciate a song with meaningful lyrics that make you think and atleast decent music. There is atlease one song like that in every genre. There's nothing too meaningful about "lean wit it rock wit it" but if you dive into some artists like nas, jay z, talib kwali, the roots, common, etc., they have very deep intellectual lyrics that the "party rap" crowd usually don't understand. Especially nas. What they do is make the "party songs" so people will buy their albums and ultimately the buyers will hear their real stuff after the "party tracks".