The snag for me is that lyrics are pointless for me - it's about tunes, so somebody rapping is (to me) being a poet
They're rapping to music. It's not at all like poetry. There's a difference between "Spoken word" and "Rap". Rhythm is part of music.
they just don't play a musical instrument - but I also have to accept that the voice is one
I hope so, or else you can't consider what Robert Plant or (Enter favorite singer here) does as music. You ever hear Lou Reed? Is that considered "music"? Because there certainly is no melody there.
Anyway, this thread isn't about who likes what kind of music, or who decides what constitutes "music". I brought up rap as a potential market for someone trying to sell loops.
I don't know why it turned into a commentary about personal taste and subjective opinion....again.
But since it did..........
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
.......and I'm not directing this at anyone, just thinking out loud since the subject was brought up....I think there's a little bit of generational and racial prejudice when it comes to how people perceive rap/hip-hop. A lot of people complain about the "violent" and "sexist" content. Boo Hoo....
But those same people never had a problem when old white men were singing about the exact same topics. I mean, "Outlaw Country" was all about "Posse's, running from the law, shooting people, etc..." When Johnny Cash sings "I shot a man in Reno just to watch him die", people think that's so cool. He's such a hero. What a badass. But heaven forbid a rap artist utter those same words.
Alice Cooper used to chop up a baby (doll) on stage.
Freddy sings "Mama, I just killed a man. PUT A GUN AGAINST HIS HEAD, PULLED MY TRIGGER NOW HE'S DEAD", and people celebrate that song as being so "touching" and "heart warming". Lol.
As far as "sexism" is concerned, rock and roll has always been about sex. Millions of songs about one-night stands, picking up chicks, and some of those "chicks" were "Sweet 16" or "Just 17, you know what I mean".
But nobody ever had a problem with it. I still don't, but I also don't have a problem with rap lyrics. Listen to some early Stones. "Stupid Girl", "Under My Thumb", "Stray Cat Blues" ("I can see that you're just 13 years old")....and many more. I can go on. But I just wanted to address the hypocrisy of how certain music is harshly judged.
^^^^I probably went a little too off topic. There's a good chance I come back tomorrow and delete most of this. I might have ventured into territory that belongs in an off topic forum. If so, I apologize.
Again. It wasn't directed at anyone. Just a 3 coffee rant on a Saturday morning.