Agreed. But wouldn't you say that knowing which take is a turd and which is the keeper (and the right way to record it) is a big step towards getting the right end product?
And that's just if you're a hired gun (like I am also.) If you are a self-recording musician or band, or even one that is going into someone else's studio, knowing when you're ready to actually hit that big red record button is *huge*.
IME, the biggest factor in today's independant recording scene that hurts the average recording is the overall lack of patience; both on the performance side and on the engineering side. Rushing to get a prodcut out before the band is locked tight, or if the band is OK, before the mix is done properly and completly, is, IMHO anyway, one of the biggest problems there is.
G.