BrettB said:
I don't think there is one great winner among them. The Squiers have a good reputation though.
My young brother-in-law is on his 3rd Squire bass in less than a year because of the same problem... the pots on the volume and tone controls are pure crap. His volume dial puked out on two consecutive basses, and this is a kid who only sits and plays with his school Jazz-band, not some wailing, high-energy Rock band. Fortunately he got replacement basses because of the one-year warranty, but based on two bad ones in a row, I'd have to suggest steering clear of the Squire basses.
I think Yamaha makes some of the better entry-level basses for the money. Ibanez makes some decent ones too. Of course, all the entry-level basses mentioned here are manufactured by Samick of Korea. But the suppliers for the electronic components are chosen by the company whose name appears on the headstock. So the Squires probably are getting cheaper electronics than the Yamaha, Ibanez, and Samick basses. Either that or the point of final inspection is lacking for the Fender products.
Some Asian-made guitars and basses have excellent final inspections and set-ups done on them.
For example, Cort guitars and basses are manufactured in multiple locations in Asia (Korea and Indonesia) but the final assembly, set-up, and inspections are done here in the U.S. at Cort's Northbrook, Illinois headquarters. Cort has excellent quality control due to this process, but they cost a bit more than the other Asian-made basses because of it.
You get what you pay for, eh?
I'd have to say that the best bang-for-your-buck basses right now are the one's with the Samick name on the headstock, more specifically, the Greg Bennett line. Samick is out to prove that good looks, great tone and high-quality can be achieved at an affordable price. They put a BIG emphasis on quality-control on the products with their name on it.
So far, they've proven their point.