creep

  • Thread starter Thread starter dobro
  • Start date Start date
dobro

dobro

Well-known member
I don't know if this is the right forum, but on the other hand, I don't know if it's the wrong forum, either, so here's a link:

YouTube - Radiohead - Creep

It's Radiohead doing 'Creep'. It's looks like it's being recorded live, but I don't see how his voice can be so clear when the band's playing full loud if it's live. If that's the sound track for the video, how'd the person mixing get that much separation on the voice?
 
It's not live - they are good but they're not that good... Think that's the radio version - the album version has a lot of F's in it.
 
What makes you think this is live? This is a music video, definitely not live. Hate to break it to you, but just because you see people "performing" a song in a video, doesn't mean they're actually playing it live. That goes for every video you've ever watched. :eek:
 
Yeah, that's what I thought. So how'd they do it? Dub what I heard to the video? Or vice versa?
 
Hate to break it to you, but just because you see people "performing" a song in a video, doesn't mean they're actually playing it live. That goes for every video you've ever watched. :eek:
It would make an interesting thread, "videos that were actually played live".
Actually, no it wouldn't.
 
Lol Grim. Ok I'll start... Looooool love the band though.
 
Yeah, that's what I thought. So how'd they do it? Dub what I heard to the video? Or vice versa?

They take the track (which was the radio edit) and play it while the band trollops around on the stage for the music video. Then they put the radio edit as the audio for the video they just took.
 
Videos are made after the song is recorded. You just play the song on speakers and have the band lip sync with themselves, then edit the video to match the audio.
 
They take the track (which was the radio edit) and play it while the band trollops around on the stage for the music video. Then they put the radio edit as the audio for the video they just took.

And make video edits to make it look like it's real. Not bad.
 
Dude, no offense....but I have to ask. Is this the first time you ever watched a music video????
 
When I was a kid, the big pop programme to watch was "Top of the pops". Thursday evening, my sisters and I never missed it. They'd have a selection of top 30 artists playing their current single. And the longer a song was in the charts, especially at NO.1, the more weeks you'd hear it. They had a really weird way of doing it though, because of the Musicians union. The band/artist would turn up at the BBC studios, rehearse, then record the song. Then when it came to the actual programme, they'd mime to the already that day recorded version of the single that was in the charts. Bizarre. You'd get the audience prancing about and they looked so funny. I know someone that used to dance on it, she gets quite embarrassed when I mention it. I think she wishes she'd never told me. Anyway, every week, at least one of the bands wouldn't actually be there {touring, rehab, etc} so these 5 sexy ladies called "Pan's people" would dance to the song. Many a young lad salivated longingly over Cherry, Babs and the other ladies.
Then as singles got more complex or bands wanted to be taken more seriously or hated the idea of being on TOTP or a particular artist wouldn't fly in from America or wherever for a one off, artists would just send videos in that would be shown while the actual single played. They were usually just a 3 minute 'movie' that somehow encapsulated the song and they were largely forgettable. They weren't called videos then. They just called them 'promo films'. They were kind of an afterthought. They weren't new though, they'd been doing them since the mid 60s. Mickey Dolenz says the Monkees used to call them "romps".
I think that the real turning point in the UK though nobody realized it at the time, was Queen's "Bohemian Rhapsody". There was no way they could perform it and as they were determined to release it as a single, they made an arty farty film to go with it. Even back when I was 12, it was impressive. The song was top of the charts for 9 weeks, so we saw it alot. Then ABBA came and knocked it off the top and I didn't see it again for 25 years or more.
And now the video is so much part of popular music, in some ways, to certain ages, more important and impact scoring than the song itself. With my kids now, though 6 and 9, they often comment that such and such a singer "isn't really singing there, are they Dad ?"
 
Lol Grim. Ok I'll start... Looooool love the band though.


WOW!!!! They must have had some SERIOUS wireless systems to be able to record on top of a mountain, not only that, but the singer must have an extremely loud voice as I can't see any vocal mic's anywhere. Maybe they used a Neumann.......
 
You mean that wasn't done live ? :laughings: I thought it was a bit lucky, the raven appearing just when it did !

In the days when smoking was allowed on the top deck of a bus there'd often be some old Greek/Mediterranean geezer sitting there, coughing his guts out, then lighting another fag. Every now and again, he'd turn and ask for a light or the time or whatever. Their voices were pretty much like the vocalist with the Gene Simmons inspired make up in the video !
 
Loool! Oh yeah and the drummer was the MOUNTAIN. Here's one that was definitley played live when recorded....caution kiddies there's a little nudity.
 
I always wondered how guitarists in videos played so precisely while jerking around like they were having a seizure. All of my practicing the moves in the mirror night after night has been a waste! They can't actually play that well while swinging their guitars around and doing karate moves? I am so disillusioned now. Oh well. So much for guitar heros.

Time to go form a dance-squad-constume-designer-and-lighting-guy as my live show and start making pop music instead. For all the ridiculous, it can't be as ridiculous as standing on a roof with your amps, but no cables, no mics, and lip synching at a camera hanging from a helicopter while trying to look "dynamic" or "expressive".

Imagine how awkward that would feel the first time if your band got asked to do that.
 
Dude, no offense....but I have to ask. Is this the first time you ever watched a music video????

Dude, I've never watched a lot of music videos, no - I don't like them very often - I don't even have TV or watch it often. But recently I've been buying some DVDs of music performances - jazzers, mostly - and I find I really like videos of live performances. And I think I'm going to get into video, so I'm starting to look at what other people have done. I think that Radiohead thing is clever - make a video that looks like live performance, but isn't - but I don't think I want to do that. But on the other hand, I don't think I want to do what those jazz DVD performances do either - simply record a live performance. I think I'd like to video voice and guitar, and then overdub parts that would be heard on the final product, but not seen of course. A sort of cross between live recording and studio recording.
 
Loool! Oh yeah and the drummer was the MOUNTAIN. Here's one that was definitley played live when recorded....caution kiddies there's a little nudity.


Yes, but no real maidens were harmed in the making of this live recording.
 
You mean this wasn't done live???



But Kirk isn't wearing tan pants. :eek:
 
I Love the "Shreds" vid's. This one's my absolute fave!
 
Back
Top