Mark H. said:
quote:
Uh-oh. Can someone explain the difference between "best produced" and "best sounding"? I'm sure it's just my ignorance, but how would they be different?
Thanks,
Mark H.
Mark, I think you've shown that you're hardly ignorant.
Jimmy Page and Phil Spector come to mind. Jimmy Page was the first guy out of the gate doing a lot of things - reverse echo, the "guitar army", or that famous drum sound on "When The Levee Breaks" - all of those things are pretty amazing, and people are still trying to duplicate a lot of his sounds today. But Led Zeppelin's albums
don't sound good! I used to think they did, until I compared Zep's albums to other albums that came out around the same time (such as IV vs. Aqualung and Who's Next, as I mentioned earlier).
I guess it's a question of what's aurally pleasing versus what's high fidelity. Why do so many guitarists prefer point-to-point soldered tube amps, versus solid state? Solid state is more electrically sound, more hi-fi. There are also lots of guitarists who prefer humbucking pickups to single-coils, despite the fact that they're muddier.
I don't particularly love the way Led Zeppelin albums sound, but I still enjoy listening to them whenever I get into that "cock rock" mood - but crisp production makes things even better. I'm very thankful that Glyn Johns made one of my favorite albums, Who's Next, sound so amazing.
In my opinion.
It's so subjective. Somebody brought up Steve Albini - he produced one of the Nirvana albums, right? In Utero, I think? I remember thinking that sounded good, but I have the album that he did with Jimmy Page and Robert Plant - Walking Into Clarksdale - and it sounds
horrible. On the single for "Most High", there's a song called "The Window", which Robert Plant's regular bassist (and son in law), Charlie Jones, produced. It puts Albini's production to shame, and makes me wonder if the album would have been more successful with a production that didn't make the music sound like it was coming out of a shoebox.
And what about the "Wall of Sound"? Could that even be done with today's more hi-fi equipment?
Speaking of hi-fi, I have to wonder what George Martin was using for playback when he was producing the Beatles. Once I upgraded my collection to CD, I could clearly hear John Lennon chewing gum on so many of those songs...
The funny thing is, it doesn't really bother me. I guess it's just John being John.