Best Home Studio Computer

  • Thread starter Thread starter solit
  • Start date Start date
S

solit

New member
I'm looking to set up a home studio with an Audiophile 2496 Soundcard.

Which Brand of computer is best?


I am leaning towards Dell, I was also considering Gateway and Sony.

Any opinions? Does it make a big difference as long as i have a generally powerful, up-to date system?

thanks!
 
The best thing to do is to put together a system yourself.......
 
Gidge said:
The best thing to do is to put together a system yourself.......

That is absolutely correct.

and stay as far away from Gateway as possible.
but of the three you listed Dell would be my choice, from experiance with people I know who actually dug themselves into the big name hell of personal computing.
 
dell vs. self built

I'm someone with minimal computer savvy, so I'm not inclined to build my own system. I would only do so if it offered such a significant advantage as to merit me putting all the time and effort into learning computer hardware.

I would rather focus my energy on teaching myself how to record music with my soundcard and software. that will be tall enough a task.

please comment on the advantages of building your own system, and what I might have to work around with a Dell PC.

thanks!
 
If you build it your own it's gonna be a lot cheaper, you'll know there're only quality components inside and you'll only get those things you need.
A pre-built system is made
a) to please as much people as possible so it will contain a lot of things not needed for audio production
b) as cheap as possible so some components will be of lesser quality.

(+ the chance a prebuilt system is badly configured is pretty high, but that's not that of a big problem)

If you want to get to know your software it'll help knowing something about how a computer works too. If not maybe you should try getting a Studio-In-A-Box.

Maybe you have a friend who's into hardware who can help you out ??


I've built some DAW's and know my way around them but the moment I can afford it I'll go with a stand-alone recorder.


Good luck,
Herwig
 
Nosferous said:
That is absolutely correct.

and stay as far away from Gateway as possible.
but of the three you listed Dell would be my choice, from experiance with people I know who actually dug themselves into the big name hell of personal computing.

Why? My notebook works great. I would say stay away from Dell. Their "award-winning" service sucks.

Unless you like sitting on the phone for 3 hours only to talk to a bumbling idiot.
 
Polaris20 said:
Why? My notebook works great. I would say stay away from Dell. Their "award-winning" service sucks.

Unless you like sitting on the phone for 3 hours only to talk to a bumbling idiot.

I say stay away from all three of them.
But over the last 5-6 years, I can't recall too many Gateway computers that have been decent, I've heard hardly any praises for gateway from people I know, nor computers I have personally been on. While I've actually heard people praise Dell computers. Though dell hasn't been out front the gate and leading as much as Gateway did over those years. But that's just a marketing thing there as to why Gateway had the that lead.

as far as lap tops/notebooks go, that's a different case. This is the place Dell takes a dive from experiance, but then again...all those laptops that had problems from Dell were running ME, so I can't really place that all in Dell's lap. Because any system running ME is high risk for many complications.

Anyone would be much better getting a pre-built computer from a smaller known company, know people that have had good experiance with google.com assembled computers. Go to sites that are known but also small production where you can select each component. Or better yet, build the computer yourself. Or at least get a bare-bones unit so the more difficult components will already be assembled. And you can hand pick the very easy installation components and get great deals for great quality.

Motherboard/heatsink installations is the most difficult part about building a computer. Everything else is pie.

another thing about the Dell, Gateway, etc. they sometimes (pretty much all production lines from dell/gateway these days) in their computer put only a limited bios, and OS install. And while most people can do just fine and dandy like that. Wanting a serious and fully operational home development PC (audio recording, video editing). Often you'll end up in there, at least once to disable or enable something. And if it's not there to even fiddle with, have patients and hope customer service is in fact there.
 
Re: dell vs. self built

solit said:
I'm someone with minimal computer savvy, so I'm not inclined to build my own system. I would only do so if it offered such a significant advantage as to merit me putting all the time and effort into learning computer hardware.

I would rather focus my energy on teaching myself how to record music with my soundcard and software. that will be tall enough a task.

please comment on the advantages of building your own system, and what I might have to work around with a Dell PC.

thanks!

Dont you have a shop local that would build one to your specs?.....
 
I agree with the Gidge...if you're not comfortable building your monster by yourself, then get a local shop to put it together for you. That way, you can select exactly what hard/software goes into your beast. Then, if you have questions or problems down the line, you'll have a local source that is familiar with your machine and will be of better service to you. Best of luck!
 
As I write this, my studio box is, well, it isn't a box anymore. It is laying in pieces all over my family room; motherboard on a bookshelf, soundcards on the mantle, harddrives and CD drives in a stack . . .

This system started life as a Gateway, which I have no objection to. I like Gateway. Still, the particular demands of recording have me in the process of making major changes.

First, the case. You'll want to consider whether the standard case is sufficient. It may be, but at a minimum, you'll want to get the full tower case. If you don't, you might find that you end up with a mini motherboard that only has 4 slots. Or you might not have enough room to add all the harddrives and CD drives, etc.

You might consider getting a rackmount case, very handy for keeping cable runs short or for making a portable studio.

The next issue is the power supply. You want to get a quiet one. There are a couple of brands that are specifically designed to be as quiet as possible. You won't get one of these in a standard box.

The other stuff--harddrives, soundcards, videocards, etc. You will usually be OK getting a stock system if you specify no soundcard and swap in your own. Having said that, I use an old video card, doesn't have very good graphics by modern standards, but who cares? It's a DAW, not a games box. I use it because it requires no fan, which keeps the system quieter.

So in conclusion I'd pick out the exact components you want, and go with the local shop route if you can't assemble yourself.

PS Anybody want to buy an old Gateway case with a noisy 200W PSU?
 
Nosferous said:
I say stay away from all three of them.
But over the last 5-6 years, I can't recall too many Gateway computers that have been decent, I've heard hardly any praises for gateway from people I know, nor computers I have personally been on. While I've actually heard people praise Dell computers. Though dell hasn't been out front the gate and leading as much as Gateway did over those years. But that's just a marketing thing there as to why Gateway had the that lead.

as far as lap tops/notebooks go, that's a different case. This is the place Dell takes a dive from experiance, but then again...all those laptops that had problems from Dell were running ME, so I can't really place that all in Dell's lap. Because any system running ME is high risk for many complications.

Anyone would be much better getting a pre-built computer from a smaller known company, know people that have had good experiance with google.com assembled computers. Go to sites that are known but also small production where you can select each component. Or better yet, build the computer yourself. Or at least get a bare-bones unit so the more difficult components will already be assembled. And you can hand pick the very easy installation components and get great deals for great quality.

Motherboard/heatsink installations is the most difficult part about building a computer. Everything else is pie.

another thing about the Dell, Gateway, etc. they sometimes (pretty much all production lines from dell/gateway these days) in their computer put only a limited bios, and OS install. And while most people can do just fine and dandy like that. Wanting a serious and fully operational home development PC (audio recording, video editing). Often you'll end up in there, at least once to disable or enable something. And if it's not there to even fiddle with, have patients and hope customer service is in fact there.

I guess it comes down to experiences. I have had good luck with my notebook, as has my sister-in-law, and I had nothing but problems with both a co-worker's desktop Dell and my old boss's Dell notebook.

In the end, I will only build my own desktops, never buy one. Even a Gateway. If I am just going to buy a computer, I'll just get a Mac.
 
I tried the build-your-own computer thing myself (1st time doing it too) here recently and I couldn't be happier. If you can read instructions and come to places like here if you have questions you can build a computer yourself. The hardest part as mentioned is installing the heatsink on the processor...the rest is pretty straightforward. Sometimes the research can be a little of a pain but overall it's not that bad. As long as your processor and memory will work with your motherboard then all you really have to worry about is soundcard compatibilty with the motherboard's chipset. Oh yeah, the heatsink/fan for the processor will require a tad amount of research for compatibility as well. The rest is pretty much common sense.

But if you don't wanna hassle with all that, a place I'd recommend would be Monarch Computer ( http://www.monarchcomputer.com/ ). You can build your own system and they've gotten good ratings over at http://www.resellerratings.com . I've dealt with em a little myself in terms of getting the motherboard for my system. Really good company to deal with! :)
 
monarch.com

basslord-
thanks for your advice. right now I am leaning toward monarchcomputer.com. seems like a good balance between the felxibility of creating my own system without the struggle of putting it all together myself.

i'm just going to buy a system custom made from them, and then I'll have to install an audiophile 2496 soundcard
 
Polaris20 said:
That's who I use. Totally reliable, and cheap.

and since they are located in CA, I get next day delivery without paying for next day shipping.

Pricewatch.com and newegg.com, my two main sources when it comes to basic components- elsewhere when it comes to putting neat lights and stuff in my case.
 
I found the hardest part about building my own p.c. was the software end. Installing, tweaking etc. I dread my eventual upgrade to Win XP. Starting over isn't always a good thing.
 
I use a Dell at home for recording and it works just fine. No problems. Only thing I would recommend is adding a second hard drive and doing the tune-up tips that are around here somewhere. Building a PC is OK if that's your thing but it wasn't for me.

BTW: I'm a network guy who has installed and maintained literally thousands of PCs/mainframes over the past 15+ years. My first PC was a Timex Sinclair, with 1k of RAM, that I had to solder to the main board. I'm no PC guru like some of these other guys, all I know is that my Dell works fine.

Dennis
 
hey solit-

Building a computer does seem daunting but it's not...and it's soo much cheaper. I'm putting together one right now. check out:

www.buildyourowncomputer.net

to get the basics about how the parts go together. If you decide to go this route get the parts from www.newegg.com.
 
Back
Top