Semi Long post.
Blue Bear Sound said:
Lastly - don't forget - while everyone seems to be comparing mics to Neumanns, and while Neumanns are excellent mics - a Neumann isn't always the right mic for the job.......
Im sorry Bruce..I can't let this go

Your comment leads me into deeper ideas.
That very statement is the one that sorta drive Harvey Gerst to sincerely evaluate mics of all levels. To see where each mic fits into the AE puzzle. I think people spend alot of time trying to make absurd comparison when they really don't have to. I spent a day or two sorta going around the cheap vs not so cheap comparison with Joe Chicarelli. Im pretty sure Fletcher could spend several weeks expounding on this subject. I got cheap mics, but those mics were purchased to fill a need. They are also purchased on a specific budget. Harvey made recommendations and Im thankful because they work for what I needed them for. I think if we teach people (esp newbies) about the vast variations of quality, character and cost in a way that they can make decisions based upon reality. Fletcher knows its the sound and quality of the mic that matters most, he has said many times he couldn't really care who makes it if the sound and quality is right for the intended purpose. Harvey said the same thing essentially, same with Joe C and Al Schmitt. When Joe uses
a KSM44 its based upon meeting the requirement of making it sound that way he thinks it should sound. There is no one mic that is the end all, be all of all mics...
It is entirely possible that these mics sound pretty good for the price range, and you might be able to find one out of the lot that sounds 99 percent of the way there in sounding like a U87...but you have to audition it in real world scenario's. Im not buying anything off of Ebay, I need at least a week of experimenting with it. Or it has to recommended by a knowledgeble AE who has used it and has seen whether or not is sounds like a U87.
So instead of jumping on the newbie with such vigor of crushing him with antinewbisitc rebellion, teach him like Harvey would, or did as I would say I guess.
Id like to hear folks just for once go "hey I found a relatively cheap condensor for $xxx.xx, what are your thoughts and are they worth the advertised price?" Be nice!
More thought later maybe?
SoMm