cool music man, but youd def benefit from a tronnier sample playback. vocals sound alot like a younger roger waters! The mellotron4000d is ridiculous, ive tried it out not so long ago. ALL mellotron chamberlin optigan talentmaker and orchestron sounds on ONE machine, thats over 200 24 bit uncompressed samples for about 1800. Real mellotron keyboard. Its as close to the real thing as possible. Memotrons are horrid. i have one as well and its just no good unfortunately. the M Tron pro software is faaaar superior.
M-tron is a bit of a dead loss for my setup, no windows to run it on, and I'd rather not have to mess around with cleaning out its hutch and keeping it updated. That's really why I went for a DOS-based approach - you can just switch it on and off as needed because it doesn't keep the filesystem open. But it is not without its problems either.
Frankly, the EQ of the source samples leaves something to be desired. It does a good job on the choir, though.
I use real mellotrons though for my songs. I have a few tape sets in my library, not too many but..enough to have my favorite sounds on. IE strings, brass, saxophones, vibraphones, piano. etc.
I usually amp the mellotron through a tube amp, blast it...and mic it about 6 feet away. Compress and reverb it a bit. usually cut some high end since most of the sounds can be quite shrill.
how did you record your tune?
Let's see. First the song was planned out and composed in SONAR. And no, SONAR 1.0 does not like running VST or DXI plugins, I tried that for the electric pianos in 2005 and it was a total disaster, which involved me recording the piano part with the tape machine running slow because it insisted on playing back at the wrong sample rate and therefore pitch. But only when it was chasing timecode.
Because SONAR and timecodes get on like mice and poison, I convert the project to MIDI and load it into Rosegarden, which actually works but is less comfortable for composing. I stripe track 8 on a TSR-8 with the timecode and overdub the instrumental tracks one by one. Sadly they are all sequenced because I am an incapable keyboard player.
I record the vocals last of all, typically though a Watkins copicat and a TLA FAT-1 compressor, though on the 'Three Little Pigs' album I played around with distortion and chorusing a lot more. If you go back a page or two in this thread you should find 'Anathema' which uses a Rotosphere Leslie simulator on the final chorus.
For the mellotron sounds, I will either use the DOS PC thing I built, or if tuning is more critical than authenticity I will sometimes use a Roland MVS-1, typically for the flutes. It doesn't do the choir that well and the strings, while sounding fuller are obviously sampled from just two notes and if you listen to it enough you'll hear the looping.
Until about September, I had a problem where the tron playback was too quiet and you could hear the PC bus coming through. When 'Three Little Pigs' was taped, I fixed this by cutting the top end a lot. Since then I modified the mixing engine to be less conservative and doubled the output level which solved that problem and gives me a lot more flexibility with the EQ. IIRC Anathema was done after that fix (unless I did it later and rerecorded the Tron lines for the final master?)
It is interesting to point out that my mellotron box has a couple of quirks - it reloads the sample set from a compactflash card when you change patch, which takes about 15 seconds, so the real thing is quicker at changing banks.
Also, it can only hold one sound set at one time, so like the real thing if you want to use two sounds in the same song, you have to overdub them.
EDIT:
And yes, Sonar is now on something like 10.0, but since Window 7 dropped support for my MIDI gear, I have taken to running Sonar entirely in linux now and I'm a little reluctant to upgrade it since it will almost certainly break.
EDIT EDIT:
For more complex arrangements I will lock two TSR-8s together. For the curious the equipment is here:
http://dougtheeagle.com/equip.htm