why is it that the guy that wrote the tune can't do it? thats what i was wondering the whole time that i was trying to play to it. that guy should know more than anyone what he wants to hear.
It's a fair question, and it'll take me awhile to explain, but I sort of want to. Here's how it happened:
I have come to know and respect a singer/songwriter by the name of David Ramirez (different singer than this guy). I've known him for a few years, and we've played in the same circles, and my daughter has played probably a hundred gigs with him.
So a few months ago, after a gig, he told me he liked the recordings I'd done with my daughter, and he asked me if I'd be interested in recording some songs before he went to Nashville to book 3 weeks of studio time. Basically, he wanted something to be able to give to the session players ahead of time so that he wouldn't be spending any unnecessary time/money in the studio.
So I invited him over right then, we recorded all night (just vocals and acoustic guitars), and then over the course of the following days, I started mixing. While mixing, I had production ideas like "this song needs a shaker," so I did it...then I decided "these songs need bass," so I played it. Then I decided "these 2 songs need drums and electric guitar," so I got those...I did tons of background vocals, etc.
Long story shortened a little bit, David ended up with 4 songs that blew him away with stuff he wasn't expecting... fully arranged and produced, and even though he got them cut in a "real" studio a few months later, I can't tell you the number of people that have told me that they preferred my mixes...probably because I'm a huge fan and I was able to take more time. There's as much "me" in those songs as there is David, and I'm proud of them.
ANYWAY, one of the guys who heard those mixes is the artist who wrote this song. David calls me one day and asked how much I would charge to record a buddy songwriter of his (this guy). I told him I've never charged for recording people, but I have the luxury of ONLY recording people whose music I love...so I asked him if the guy was good. David's honest response was that he had a good voice, but he was "still working" on the songwriting. I told him I'd do it so long as the guy (who drove 200 miles from Houston to get here) would get here at noon on a Saturday and be gone eight hours later. Well, the guy showed up at 3 and I finally kicked him out of my house at 11pm...on a Sunday, and I didn't like the songs honestly. And he brought this other guy with him that I swear to God looked like he just picked him up hitchhiking...this other guy was the "lead guitar" player, but he was so fucking baked that no matter how loud I ran the click, he just couldn't play in time...or in key. It was laughable. I really should have saved those tracks, but I deleted them the minute they left my house. Then the songwriter got kind of pushy in the next few days when it came to giving him samples of the mixes, and he was making noise about coming back to do "another couple of songs," so I basically said "Fuck this...I'm not working for this asshole...hell, I'm not working for ANYBODY." It still kind of stuns me that somebody I don't know would take advantage of almost 8 hours of my time and eat my pizza and drink my wife's beer, then expect me to just JUMP RIGHT ON that free mixing job, and then ASK TO COME BACK FOR MORE, lol.
Anyway, a week after he left, my audio interface died. This was fine with me, because I was burned out on music, and it gave me a great excuse not to have to mix this guy's songs. Out of 5 songs, 4 of them were over 5 minutes long, LOL. The tune in this thread is by far the best tune, and I actually ended up kind of liking it, but the bottom line is that I told him my shit was broken, and I'd be happy to mail him his files so that he could find somebody to mix them. I didn't hear back from him on that offer.
But a weird thing happened. I actually felt shitty for not finishing the stuff for him. Like it or not, I said I would...so last week when I got my firepod fixed and bought some new monitors, I decided that it might mend some fences if I gave him more than he was expecting. So I did background vocals and electric guitars and drums and bass and acoustic leads, etc.
When I sent him the first song this week (with a "hey, I got my stuff fixed, and here's one of your songs") emails, he was sort of overjoyed and really apologetic and it just confirmed that I was being a dickhead and this was the right thing to do.
So to answer your question...the reason he didn't give me the chords or play bass on it is because it was basically a surprise for him necessitated by my own douchebaggery.
That's pretty long and honest, lol.