Any small and good tube amp will start (new) at $500 bucks. The BJ is good, but does one thing and does it really well. At $50 to $100 bucks a pop, adding on all the pedals you would need to be able to do what the Vox AD amp does you are looking at around $1000 bucks for everything (amp + pedals). Yeah change the tubes, but you also have to change the speaker. Hard to beat the sound of a real
Jensen C12K or a 100 watt Weber Blue Dog inside a BJ amp. Better yet, stick an Emi Cannabis Rex in there!!
You wanna spend $1000 bucks?
The Cubes are ok, but all solid state cant match the tone of any tube, even if it is just a 12AX7 in a power amp section that gets boosted later by a SS power stage to feed the speaker. The Vox will hold up under the conditions you describe (recording at home, no gigs, no rehearsals). Change the tube, but - again - you have to change the speaker. That budget custom Celestion C50 (I think) that they put in there sucks. Put a 100 watt 10 inch Weber Blue Pup in there and it will sing. Better yet, mount a shorting jack on the back (careful - voids the warranty) so you can plug it into a 100 watt Weber Blue Dog or a Michigan and you will be glad you paid $239 for the AD30. For $500 bucks, the same cost of a BJ, you can have the AD30, the Weber Blue Pup, a new cord and a new leather strap and have plenty of variety to fill your needs. And if it's too loud at 2am, it has a power soak on the back to set the speaker volume without changing your knobs settings. Crank the gains full and scream away.....
I got
an AD30 just for taking to church, so I dont have to lug around a box full of pedals. I put a Emi Delta Demon in it, and a shorting jack to connect to any 8 ohm cab. Sounds great thru a 2x12. Since you emphasized variety at home, the AD30 (or
the AD50 for another $120 bucks!) beats any of the other choices you list.
But for recording?? Fire up the Twin or the Mesa!! If I had money to burn?? I would have a THD BiValve sitting here!!