easy,...EASY regebro. i'm sure the Caped Green Crusader was just trying to help. he loves his AW2816 (and understandably so,..it's a FINE machine). the Aw16G is DEFINETLY a step down from the AW4416 AND the AW2816. THAT SAID,...the 16G appears to be a nice little unit. i'll "attempt" to explain the "good" and the "bad" here:
FOR THE SAKE OF MY FINGERTIPS i'll abbreviate
the AW16G to the "G" and i'll condense the AW2816 to the "28".
1) BOTH have 16-track playback. duh.
2) BOTH have dynamics on (at least) each playback channel. cool.
3) BOTH have an onboard CD burner. great.
4) the G has sample pads...the 28 does not. advantage G (me likey).
5) the 28 has a MUCH bigger display screen. advantage 28 (NICE).
6) the G has "realtime" knobs for eq and other tweaks. advantage G (what were they
they thinking when they left those off the 28??)
7) the 28 has monitor outouts as well as FOUR seperate assignable outs
(the G has monitor outs which DOUBLE as AUX outs.....either/or). if you
have extra gear to interface the 28 has a big advantage in this department.
i have a few reverbs and delays that i CAN'T live without. advantage 28.
8) the 28 (despite only 8 faders) has NO shared tracks (unless you want it to).
the G appears to sum the last 8 tracks to stereo (i.e 9/10, 11/12, 13/14, 15/16)
each with a SINGLE fader. may or MAY NOT be a problem.
9) the 28 CAN record at 24 BITS. the G CANNOT. BIG advantage 28.
10) the 28 has onboard automation. the G appears to NOT HAVE automation of
ANY KIND. seems to be a HUGE advantage for 28.
11) the 28 has an expansion slot (the ubiquitous WAVES card?). the G has none.
may or may not be important.
12) the G is smaller and easier to transport. may or may not be important.
13) both have "what appears to be" similar effects processors.
14) both have plenty of virtual tracks (8 extra per track?)
i think the G is a cool little unit. it looks like an easy to use 16-bit recorder with an
onboard cd burner and a handy little sampling function. i has some sort of "auto record" deal that is supposed to "capture your musical ideas while you are doodling about with the recorder". not sure exactly what that is but it seems kinda cool. BOTTOM LINE IS: is the G a handy little recorder that is easy to use?......YES! can you record and mixdown a song to cd?...YES! will it "sound" as good as the 24-bit capabilities of the 28?? NO!!!!
an AW2816 with a WAVES card installed can pretty much kick the living crap out of just about any standalone unit out there (aside from
the Akai DPS24, maybe). BUT,...it boils down to BUDGET and NEED. do you NEED the capabilites that the 28 (or the 4416) offers OR are you looking for a sturdy little 16-bit recorder? do you plan on having massive amounts of instrumentation that might require automated mixing? do you plan to record "delicate" voices and acoustic instruments and expect the HIGHEST degree of detail? do you want to "master" your project on your DAW?
just depends on what you want, reg. the 28 has more to offer "if you want it". the G is a great recorder "if it's all that you need". cheers.
