Moptop, if you are reading, my intention was not to offend you. I'm just pointing out that reciprocity has to be the foundation of a collective undertaking like the Mp3 Clinic. Most of us are songwriters or musicians working to improve our stuff. We give suggestions to each other in hopes of receiving back the same. Imagine if we all did as you have done--posting in hopes of comments without reciprocating. Then none of our songs would get comments, and there would be no purpose in posting here all at. You do as you please. Nobody will stop you. Others are free to comment or not, as they please. But understand, those of us who are regulars here notice the patterns over time. When I notice a poster who repeatedly fails to reciprocate, I stop commenting on their songs. I don't think I'm alone there. You seemed a little miffed at the shortage of comments on this thread (since you erased your earlier posts, that context is gone), so I pointed it out to you. I was not trying to chase you away.