Alright, since you asked ... it's different every time. Depends on how the kit is set up and how much space you have to work with and what's available in terms of gear. It appears you like to rent, which is smart. I do that a lot, too, because it's pretty cheap and you can get a hold of some nice stuff. And Geffels are good. Using good mics is a good thing. Yippee skippy. Rock on. But I wouldn't over-estimate their value in getting good drum tracks.
Most important thing is to work with a good kit, and some nice, low-key cymbals that record smoothly. After that, worry about getting them tuned right, with the proper amount of tensioning. New heads are almost always a must. I hate felt beaters in most cases, for example. This stuff makes up about 99% of the sound. From there, I look at it as my job to just "not get in the way" of it. I stick with simple methods without getting cute or overly ambitious. In other words, my role, in the bigger picture, is pretty insignificant.
I can help the drummer by advising him what kind of cymbals record well (Kustom K Darks, for example) ... if I can convince him to change his heads ... to loosen the front head on his kick, or to rent an entirely different kit altogether if I think it's necessary, and I'm successful in my pleas ... then I've made a much more significant contribution to the quality of the recording.
Most of the time, though, I'm a monkey boy and I just do the best with whatever crap I'm given.

Most people don't complain about the drum sounds I get. Come mixdown ... yea they want their kick to be all clickety-clackety or they want it to push the subwoofer and they want the snare to explode with tons of reverb like in old Chili peppers or Flaming Lips records or whatever.

Now I'm just babbling.