I can't believe I forgot to respond to this ... there's actually a funny story there, but I'll cut to the chase.
1000% Better
Yes, I realize that doesn't make a lot of mathematical sense, but it's heartfelt.
There are a ton of good things to talk about, but I'm hoping they've been covered...just assume I agree with those.
Now, I loved the guitar tone FOR THIS SONG. I think if you'd tried it on another tune, I'd not like it...but it's almost an effect on this one. If that was intentional, you rule. If it wasn't intentional, you rule.
cons - I think it's the drums...I don't know for sure, honestly, b/c I can never figure stuff like this out unless I'm physically able to adjust and hear, but I think the drums are smaller than they should be. Maybe a volume thing, maybe a panning thing, maybe a compression thing, maybe a "chris is stupid, b/c they're fine" thing, but SOMETHING is keeping this from sounding huge.
My bad for not responding earlier.
I'll read the thread now and see if you got new gear.