Soundproof booth for practising purposes (WhisperRoom)?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SSam
  • Start date Start date
S

SSam

New member
Hi,I'm looking for close to soundproof booth for practising purposes (saxophone and other woodwinds,(amplified) harmonica etc.,no drums) to be used in an apartment building 24/7 without disturbing neighbours.Booth would have to be soundproof to a degree that it can let out some noise outside the booth to my apartment but not to neighbouring apartments (apartment has concrete walls ,quite thick).The best option for now is the WhisperRoom http://www.whisperroom.com/hompage.html.I'm looking for any information how soundproof WhisperRooms are in real use(standard wall models),those db diagrams don't tell the whole truth.Any info on this is appreciated,thanks!
 
Considering the parameters that you have laid out I think that a Whisperroom would give you sufficient isolation to meet that need.

Now, if you are reasonably handy you could most likely save yourself some dollars by doing a DIY whisper room for personal use.
 
Hello Ssam.
Have you had complaints from neighbors already? Whisperrooms are designed for hearing tests. Have you ever had one? Heres the deal. They put you in this booth, put a pair of headphones on you, and play VERY low level sounds at various frequencies to see what you hear. Usually, these booths are in a hearing doctors "facility", which could be anything from a Mall storefront, to an individual building. The booth is designed to keep out sound that may mask the low level sounds. However, since this booth is in a quiet room already, it is sounds OUTSIDE the building that are the point of the booth...sirens, helicopters, planes, busses, traffic, and things of that nature. However, by the time these sounds infiltrate the room, they have already decreased in amplitude, to an average that the designers have determined is "normal" within a room. Since you have headphones on, this is a second line of defense against intruding sound as well. Needless to say, they are NOT designed to keep HIGH SPL sounds from transmitting FROM the booth into the surrounding room, although they are rated for speech level sounds from transmitting. It MAY muffle a sax, to the point where your concrete walls will have enough transmission loss to prevent transmission from occuring, but thats impossible to say.

The ONLY way to know what you are generating in SPL for sure, is to play while someone takes sound level readings on a Sound Level meter, then compare it to the specs on the whisperoom doc's. Even then, you are still pretty much guessing about transmission through the concrete walls. You would have to measure the sound TRANSMITTING through the concrete envelope into an adjacent space to know "concretely" :D

For absolute guaranteed results, a booth with a TRANSMISSION LOSS RATING to exceed what you are generating would have to be built. Not an easy task. Especially if you wanted it to be dismantled for moving to another location. For one, a booth with high spl transmission loss will be EXTREMELY heavy, as a TWO LEAF-MASS AIR MASS assembly with one leaf decoupled is the best bang for the buck assembly for reducing sound transmission. This means floor, walls, and ceiling. In terms of generally speaking, this would be an assembly with one or two framing assemblies, with an exterior mass of at least 2 layers of 5/8" drywall, a minimum hermetically sealed airgap of 4" filled with batt insulation(more if possible), and a decoupled interior leaf of at least 2 layers of drywall(you may substitute MDF for drywall, a massive door(OR 2 depending on LOW FREQUENCY TL requirements) with double seals, and then, the granddaddy of the solution delimas...ventilation. This is why Whisperoom designs are NOT suitable for high spl TL. They couldn't possibly build a PORTABLE unit with the mass and decoupling required, as it would indeed be so heavy as to make shipping extremely expensive, difficult to build as a portable product, and ventilation requirements which would require venting to exterior sources. But these are my own "opinions" and suffer from lack of information on your apartment envelope TL, and your sound generating SPL facts.
fitZ
 
Thanks for your replys.WhisperRoom,according to their website,is actually designed for instrument practising purposes;to keep soundlevels low outside the booth.That is how I've been informed by them and on their customer feedback page there are lots of rewievs by trumpet and sax players who have bought WhisperRoom for practising purposes.I need soundproofing inside out,not the other way.WhisperRooms are not totally soundproof,I agree with Rick that soundproofing needs extremely materials to work well.WhisperRoom size 211cm x 112cm weighs 205kgs,not extremely heavy but not light either.Playing sax produces approx 70 up to 100 dbs and all I'm really interested is if WhisperRooms work well enough keeping soundlevels low on apartment building.
 
Back
Top