I'd be interested to hear how it turns out. One of my Strat necks has a satin finish and it has an excellent feel. If the neck is natural and a bolt on maybe you might think about removing it and sanding it down and spraying on a satin finish,
2 cents worth of......if I knew what I was talking about I'd be rich.
I've done a few of my necks. I started with 80 grit in an orbital sander to hog off the thick part . Then 120, 180 and 220. I did finish both necks with TruOil and lightly buffed with 0000 steel wool. It works for me.
I have a few baseball bats. They're OK but I prefer a thinner neck. I took the poly off the neck, re-shaped the headstock to Tele style and finished it with TruOil as usual. Top is
stock headstock shape. Next is after I carved on it a bit.