I like reamping because
I read just about everything in this thread. I see pro's an con's to a lot of different peoples points. I also see some that just cant seem to ever give a real life example, they are always just spewing their sheltered know it all opinion when in actuality they probably have never been directly involved in doing it.
I will say I am completely convinced that re-amping is the way to go for me in order to get the result I wanted.
Ill just add my 2 cents to how re-amping can help you like it did me.
I recently released this album using re-amping techniques on the guitars and bass. You be the judge and ask yourself can you get a guitar and cab to sound at least this good? Same with the bass and overall mix
Scream at the Sun
Re-amping was great because I was spending money on making a nice sounding album(IMO) and I did not want to mess it up myself. I wanted a professional to make it sound as good as it could. Recording and music production is an art and some people really know how to do it. I do a little, but not enough to risk making my album sound less than
stellar.
I recorded all the parts on Pro Tools LE at 88.2k in my basement using a cheesy plug-in that I dialed in pretty good in order for me to perform my best when recording each track. I then took off all the plug-ins leaving a dry clicky guitar signal. I then bounced those dry clicky guitar signals down to wave files. I then sent them (and the entire tracks of the whole album) to the studio of my choice via the internet uploading/downloading. I live in Minnesota and I sent them to
a cool cat in Long Island NY and let him since he REALLY knows what he is doing re-amp everything using the best known modified amps on the planet (which I do not have).
So all my guitars were re-amped with a Barron K2 which is about a $4k amp, not sure about the cab, but the point is this... Re-amping saved me a ton of time and money. I was able to track everything on my own at my own time and then negotiated a fair price for the professional studio to do the entire album in one price. If I had done the usual which is book studio time at an hourly rate and then try to cram all the performances into one session then I may not be as happy with my "one shot" performance as being able to comfortably do it on my own time, I did not have to pay an hourly rate to track.
Basically the re-amping process give you unlimited options. As long as the dry tracks exist almost anything can be done with them.
I wish I could do music production as good as this guy that did my album or true professionals in general, but reality is, for me writing and creating the music is where it's at and letting someone who is really good at the production side of things do their thing and hopefully the two talents will create something really good.
This is one real life example of how re-amping can be used to benefit you. I hope this helps you in making the best decision for yourself.
I will also add one thing that will save you lots of time. Once you have your final performance tracked, be sure to do all the editing of the tracks like eliminating string noises before each part sounds, snapping to grid, fades etc.. on your dry tracks BEFORE re-amping otherwise you will have to edit every single track you re-amp.
cheers.