Turn off the EQ. Actually, turn off all your recording stuff, and make it sound right coming out of the amp. THEN, turn your recording stuff back on, and make it sound right by just moving the mic around. And I don't mean make it sound great. I mean make it sound right. As in, right for the track. Which may well sound like shit standing in the room. Remember, the goal isn't to have a great sounding guitar track, but a great sounding final mix. They two outcomes are frequently at cross purposes.
Only then, if you still need to tweak something small, can you mess with the EQ, but try to avoid it - it never makes actually things sound better. Well, almost never. Nine times out of ten, you'll spend an hour tweaking the EQ, and when you A/B it bypassed, it sounds better bypassed.
Light
"Cowards can never be moral."
M.K. Gandhi