Lesson learned - Mic Placement

  • Thread starter Thread starter NegadivOne
  • Start date Start date
NegadivOne

NegadivOne

Alchemy slut
Let me start by saying that Im not looking for a pat on the back or anything, I just wanted to try and help to show how important proper mic placement is. Ive been drumming for about 7 years, recording for 3 or 4. Ive only been serious about recording for the past few months though. I always heard people talk about how important mic placement is, but I never understood how someone could spend an hour setting up one mic...untill a couple days ago. My girlfriend was out of town and I had nothing to do so I decided to spend the day in my studio and try to work on improving my drum recordings. There are clips here http://www.soundclick.com/bands/pagemusic.cfm?bandID=500073, OldMicPlacement, and NewMicPlacement. I used the same drums, mics, recorder, room, everything the same for both recordings. I didnt even retune the heads from the old one to the new one. The only thing that is different is I used a different snare for the new clip. I encourage you to listen to the old clip first.

My Setup:

Drums: Taye StudioMaple 6 pc.
Mics:
Kick - Shure Beta52
Snare - Shure SM57
Toms - Shure SM57's
Overheads - AT P650R's (I think they are discontinued)
Recorder: Fostex VF160

OLDMICPLACEMENT: This clip is the result of about a months worth of work on these drum tracks. I had to do a lot of eq, and a lot of general tweaking to make them sound this good. I even did the trick of really compressing a submix of the drums and bringing them up under the uncompressed drums. I cut out all the parts of the trackes that werent needed, ie: i cut out the tom tracks when the toms werent being played, to try to get it as clear as possible. This is the best I could make these tracks sound. The overhead mics I just put up in L and R spaced pair. I didnt even really experiement with them, just threw them up when i got them and left them in the same place for all my recordings. The Beta52 is right in the hole on my bass drum head. The snare and toms are all close miced with 57's about an inch from the heads.

NEWMICPLACEMENT: This clip is the recording I made after a whole day of working on mic placement. The only things I did were: I tracked with a LITTLE bit of compression this time. I added just a little bit of reverb to cover up the sound of my bad room (same reverb and same amount as in the other drum clip). I added no other effects and no eq except for pulling a tiny bit of mids out of the kick. I didnt do anything to the toms and they sound killer. I used to have to eq the crap out of them and they always used to sound hollow and cardboard-y. This is the best my drums have ever sounded on a recording and I didnt even tune them before I recorded. The overheads I have in an XY pattern, and the snare is still really close miced, but now the 57's on the toms I put about 3 or 4 inches from the head. The Beta52 is about 3 inches from the beater side head, pointed at the beater.

I just wanted to share my personal revolation about the importance of mic placement. The guys on these boards really do know what they are talking about most of the time. I learned everything I know on these boards. Thanks everybody!
 
Last edited:
awsome man, I am just going to start tracking drums on my own for the first time(no more single mic in the room) and your experiences give me hope yet, lots of work to do. Thanks for sharing!
 
DeadUnion said:
awsome man, I am just going to start tracking drums on my own for the first time(no more single mic in the room) and your experiences give me hope yet, lots of work to do. Thanks for sharing!

No problem, glad I could help. Just take your time with everything and Im sure it will turn out well.
 
are the 57's on the toms pointing to the center of the toms? and is the bass drum mic (beta 52 ) through a hole in the resonant side of the bass drum or have you taken that skin off completely? Thanks and sounds killer man thanks for sharing.
 
breeeeza said:
are the 57's on the toms pointing to the center of the toms? and is the bass drum mic (beta 52 ) through a hole in the resonant side of the bass drum or have you taken that skin off completely? Thanks and sounds killer man thanks for sharing.

I have 4 toms, 2 rack toms and 2 floor toms. I have one 57 between the two rack toms, and one 57 between the two floor toms. so they are actually pointing kind of at the rims between the toms. Ill try to put up some pics here today. And the kick mic is going through the hole on the resonant side, I still have it on. And also I have a blanket over my bass drum to keep the other drum noises out too. Thanks for checking it out man.
 
Here are some pics.

OLD SETUP

You cant see the way the overheads used to be but you can see one of the stands in the first pic. They were just pointed straight down at the cymbals.
Picture003.jpg


Picture004.jpg


NEW SETUP

dobledo001.jpg


dobledo002.jpg


dobledo003.jpg
 
it's to bad you can't mic all the toms that would sound killer totally panned out you know......

I've spent literally like 10 hours trying to get good sounds out of drums. I always make it a point to get the best doing nothing other than good mic placement.
 
killmachine said:
it's to bad you can't mic all the toms that would sound killer totally panned out you know......
Yeah I think about that all the time. My recorder can do 8 tracks at once and Im only using 6 so the possibility to mic all the toms would be there, but a while ago a F@%$#&* guitarist I was recording plugged straight from his amps head into my recorder and blew the first two tracks. So untill I can afford to pay 75 bucks an hour to get it fixed, I can only mic half my toms.

I've spent literally like 10 hours trying to get good sounds out of drums. I always make it a point to get the best doing nothing other than good mic placement.
I used to think people like you were crazy for doing that but after doing that myself, its the only way to go.
 
First off, your druming is killer. I think your toms sound excellant. I;m going to try and get my tom mics a little further away from the heads like yours and see what happens. Your kick is tight and punchy, what everyone strives for and it almost seems a little too tight for my taste, but your the guy behind the wheel. I've tried the small condenser's x position before. I always go back to using two stands for each sc and spreading them apart facing striaght down. But hey my room is different. Overall excellant sound my friend. I personally love the sound of a deep snare and I use the same evans head as you and man it tames the ring of a deep maple snare.
 
gcapel said:
First off, your druming is killer. I think your toms sound excellant. I;m going to try and get my tom mics a little further away from the heads like yours and see what happens. Your kick is tight and punchy, what everyone strives for and it almost seems a little too tight for my taste, but your the guy behind the wheel. I've tried the small condenser's x position before. I always go back to using two stands for each sc and spreading them apart facing striaght down. But hey my room is different. Overall excellant sound my friend. I personally love the sound of a deep snare and I use the same evans head as you and man it tames the ring of a deep maple snare.

Thanks for the compliments man! Im blown away by my toms too i didnt know they could sound that good. Youre right about the kick though thats the only thing im not completely happy with. I love deep snares too. I have a deeper snare that came with the kit that i always used to use but lately its had a severe ringing problem i cant solve so ive been using my other snare. Its a pacific 805 i think 14x4 or something. Not my first choice but its all i got to work with.
 
Nice Job

Nice Job Negadiv- and kudos for posting details, pics, and clips!
Cheers, Rez
 
RezN8 said:
Nice Job Negadiv- and kudos for posting details, pics, and clips!
Cheers, Rez

Thanks, I usually just ask questions around here so I thought I might try to actually help out, even if only a little. And thanks to MadAudio btw, it was his thread in here that inspired me to try it myself.
 
NegadivOne said:
Thanks, I usually just ask questions around here so I thought I might try to actually help out, even if only a little. And thanks to MadAudio btw, it was his thread in here that inspired me to try it myself.
And I thought it was just a coincidence! Glad I motivated you! Worth it, wasn't it?
 
MadAudio said:
And I thought it was just a coincidence! Glad I motivated you! Worth it, wasn't it?

No it definately wasnt a coincidence. I even saved your pics on my computer and referenced them while setting up my OH's. It was DEFINATELY worth it. This is the single biggest jump in recording quality Ive come across...
 
Back
Top