misterx.
To illustrate the difference between ways people write songs/lyrics,
I cannot write the lyrics, then add the music.
I've tried many times, but there lacks that bonding, relationship, between lyrics and music when I'm finished. The song usually ends up just laying around on a cassette someplace.
For me, the mesh between music and lyrics come together at the time I do it the first time. I have no idea why I do it this way. Likewise, I have no idea why anyone would do it any other way.
Heck, it works for me.
I can't write lyrics every time I pick up an insturment either.
I always use a cassette tape when I practice or create as song.
In the past I've found that when I stop playing to write it down on paper, I loose the flow/idea/feel.
When I feel I have something worth my time to go back over, I then spend some time working with it. Sometimes it isn't as good as it sounded when I first played it.
I toss it.
If I find that it has something that can be developed, I save it to another tape. I have alot of unfinished songs this way. Then when the mood hits me to edit the lyrics, I pick a song at random, ususally, and work in it.
By recording it onto cassette first thing, I don't forget the melody that got my attention right off, that I so easily forget if I don't record it. Same for the words and the music.
I'm comfortable writing a song this way.
During the editing portion of my songwriting, I feel very comfortable adjusting the music, finding a special chord for that certin word, fixing a dull spot in the melody. There is no problem doing that anytime. The lyrics are my stumbling block. If I don't get them pointed in the right direction when I play the music, I have a problem. In other words, I have to have the music/lyrics and the mood all at the same time.
I still have fun though.
Peter.
If I decide to compose music for it, I basically also start a re-write or editing of the lyrics because I am rarely able to duplicate the music in my head which I wrote the lyrics to. Sometimes I come up with a totally revamped song unlike what I originally wrote and sometimes I get something pretty close to what I had in mind
This is what I can't do.
A complete different way of writing than I do.
My way, I know is quite limited and confining, but I'm more of a musician than a songwriter. Maybe that's my problem.
Another thing I do is carry a small mini cassette recorder with me all the time. Driving, in a store, in the forest or on the toilet, I can hum a tune and the lyrics I just thought of, then fiddle with it later. Doing this, I usually only have the music, then I can fit in the lyrics on the fly.
I've taken songs apart also. Some interesting things tucked away in some styles of songwriters.