Usually any Mackie is a good mixer. I've heard the 1604VLZ, but I don't like the pre-'s in it as much as my TASCAM M-1516.
I like dedicated tape returns too. I don't want to run a split console configuration.
Don't get me wrong, the pre-'s are great in the Mackie for on-board pre-'s. I've not auditioned the VLZ Pro. You have a lot of reading to catch up on I'll bet. After I auditioned a VLZ I downloaded a manual to look over. Lot's of reading.
What kind of recorder will you be using? Dare I hope for tape?
Nah, I'm still livin' in the '80's, must be a computer, right?
You hoped right! I am using a tape recorder (and a comp also...but thats so mundane ain't it?). Fostex R-8, followed by mixdown into Cakewalk for all the EQ and other miscellaneous effects!
I picked up the Mackie 1402 VLZ for $349...Mars close out.
I understand the routing options dilema...its nice to have flexibility and options but it can get overwhelming.
Now I also have another dilema for recording media.
So far I have just had a Yamaha cassette 4-tracker and no external mixer. Several months ago I picked up a GC open box Echo Darla 24/96 (wich was fried but repaired under warranty).
Now the problem...the PC is the family PC in the living room and I rarely have it to myself or quiet. The 4-tracker is in the bedroom in a homemade rack that blends with the furniture (wifes requirement).
At least I can mix and DI in the bedroom with the door shut and I will get much more time in. I could do some hybrid into the PC and roll my equipment into the living room but would only get to record 3 or 4 hours a month at most.
Wiring my rack for both possibilities with an unbalanced patchbay is a major nightmare.
I can't say it hasn't crossed my mind (or hers for that matter).
But for the sake of the kids and being a man of my word its on to plan B (which is really plan A with some unexpected complications to work out).
Hopefully in three to four years we can move to a bigger house with an additional spare bedroom for my stuff, the kids will be older and more independant...its in the plans but not the checking account yet.