You need to play them first. I own a '52 reissue with Bare Knuckle Country Boy pickups that is absolute magic. I've played some '52 and '62 customs that are absolute dogs. [I]YOU NEED TO PLAY FENDERS BEFORE YOU BUY 'EM[/I]
Another good option is assembling a parts guitar. What tone are you looking for: chickin' pickin', Keef, Albert Collins, or maybe Yardbirds/Led Zepplin?
Go to Warmoth.com and get a neck and body, then go to callaghamguitars.com and get the rest of your parts. $1300 could build somthing very nice.