Here's something you might find interesting.
Look here
It's a comparison between the following mics in this order...
Neumann U87, Studio Projects B1, B3, C3, and Oktiva MK 319 large diapraghm condensers.
Studio Projects C4, ADK SC1, AKG C451L,
C460B, small diaphragm condensers.
Shure SM 57 unidyne, dynamic.
Unfortunately it's on an acoustic guitar, but you'll get the gist.
The audio file is just the same short passage on the guitar on each mic one after the other so you'll have to have this list in front of you and keep an eye on what mic they are up to.
You'll notice that the differences are VERY subtle between the condensers, but note that the last passage is played on an SM57 which sound almost the same as your 58. But also note that they are plugged into a high-end preamp so the SM57 will sound heaps better than you Behringer mixer makes it sound.