D-112: Killer
The D-112 for me has become an item which i'll never get rid of. I got mine to use mainly for live sound, but it records VERY well also.
In general, it has a wider frequency response than other's i've used. That means it not only picks up the lowest of the lows, but also the "slap" of the kick drum beater. It doesn't go quite as deep as some mics, but it balances out on the other end. What you will get is an amazingly accurate reproduction of the kick drum's actual sound.
What it WON't do, is make a crappy kick drum sound better than it is. If you've got good heads, and they're properly tuned, even cheap drums sound good with the D-112.
It's also versatile. If you want to mic a good bass cabinet, the D-112 will work amazingly well. I even know someone who used one on a set of timpani with killer results.
If you shop around, I'm sure you can find one for less than $200. I got mine at Mars Music for $190 because it was a floor display, and that was two years ago.