I don't like Pink Floyd's (David Gilmour's) "Comfortably Numb" solo.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bubba po
  • Start date Start date
I think of Floyd in terms of the complete concepts and arrangements ...... not guitar solos although I don't tend to think in terms of solos anyway since that's what I do.
The totality of the song is my thing.
I'm pretty much the same. A solo is not a song although there are hundreds of solos that I adore. But I wouldn't if I didn't like the song. In any given song, there'll be elements that I really dig, whether it's a "Roo-doo-doo-dood" at the end of a bass run or a particular smack of a drum. On Mahavishnu Orchestra's live version of "Dreams", where the violin and guitar are knocking out the riff towards the main frame {the song is 20 minutes long}, Billy Cobham does these 5 great whacks on the drums to bring the band into that most orgasmic of climaxes. Not 4. Not 8. Not 6. Five ! It almost kills me every time.
Fortunately, I survive.:D

Ummagumma
The Cambridge word for sex, that. "Eh luv, d'yer fancy a little ummagumma ?"
The cover of that album is one of my top 5. Fooontastic.

our favorite is "Echoes
It was originally called "Return to the sun of nothing". It was the first side long epic I ever appreciated and as the years went by, I grew to love that song. Under the influence of good old Mother Nature's finest, I used to roam the universe on this song. For me, it's the most complete progressive rock epic from the piano note at the start, right through to the swirling mellotronesque voices in the runout. There is not a single boring second in the 23 minutes, even the sound effects in the middle don't outstay their welcome.

"Set the controls for the heart of the sun."

Music isn't about solo's
Yeah, music isn't about solos but they form an important part of some pieces. A well placed and thought out solo is like having a slash while the adverts are on in the middle of a film !
"Set the controls for the heart of the sun" reveals alot about Roger Waters psyche, even as a young man of 22 or 23 or whatever. It's about a suicidal astronaut intent upon self destruction, hence, he sets the controls of his rocket for......
I think it was his observation and conclusion of Syd Barrett as Syd was way off beam by that point.
It is rumoured his guitar is buried in the mix and possibly one of the only tracks to feature his and Gilmour's guitar playing.

My favorite Floyd member was always Richard Wright.
I am with you on this one, he was a very important member of the Floyd. I like his playing and his songs. "Remember a day"
One of my earliest memories of the Floyd is "Remember a day". When I think back to the actual day I listened to them for the first time, that song is one that I remember. It was recorded for the "Piper at the gates of dawn" album but then got left off. Richard Wright was an underrated singer, an underrated songwriter and an underrated keyboardist, but as far as I'm concerned was an irreplacable element in early Floyd and beyond.
What I liked about early Floyd was that until Dave Gilmour came into the band, none of them were particularly skilful instrumentalists in any way. Roger Waters was rudimentary on bass, kind of the way Adam Clayton was with U2, Syd was an inventive but simplistic guitarist and Rick Wright got the most from the least. Nick Mason was so basic that he ended up helping to pioneer a particular style of psychedelic drumming, almost by accident. He was not so much a poor man's Ginger Baker, more a deaf in one ear destitute tramp's attempt at Ginger Baker. But all those elements together with the concept of 'the studio as an instrument' which was coming in then, combined to make wonderful music. I started learning bass because of the bass parts on those first two albums.
I also like The Monkees, Mahavishnu Orchestra and Meshuggah and The Ramones and The Ventures.
Frank Sinatra had some good stuff too.
You'd think the Monkees and the Mahavishnu Orchestra were diametrically opposed. I think both bands are wicked, both packed to the hilt with superlative songs.
I played the movie "Head" for my 10 year old son last week. He freaked out when they appear to kill themselves at the start but he really got into it as it progressed. It's such a strange little movie.
 
I played the movie "Head" for my 10 year old son last week. He freaked out when they appear to kill themselves at the start but he really got into it as it progressed. It's such a strange little movie.
It IS a strange movie and kinda finished off the Monkees 'cause no one could accept a kid's band as doing anything adult.

I have a copy also.
 
LOL - I just went to have a listen on my iPod so I could remember what I thought of it, and guess which single song is missing from my iPod's version of The Wall.... "Comfortably Numb"... I'll have to get back to you... :D
 
Brilliant song and solo, one of my all time fave floyd songs. I'll admit allways prefering the live versions over the original recording though.
 
u will once u play it
Are you saying that in order to appreciate it I have to learn it?

Well, I already have "Time" and "Shine on You Crazy Diamond" under my belt. I suppose one more bloated epic wouldn't hurt. :D
 
It was good for the day & still stands up to the test of time (no pun intended). All things are subjective, guitar solo's especially so and threads even more (LOL). Go with what you like and be eclectic in your choices. I watched a documentary about Floyd a while ago, and I think Gilour said "He was just messing about in the key of Bm", or something like that (I might be wrong).
 
Lol...I didn't read through the whole thread, but I think that is one of the better guitar solos that come to mind in rock guitar solos for me. Mother is another good one, but the beginning of Shine On You Crazy Diamond has some tasty Gilmour work. In my opinion and for my tastes, of course. I like bluesy-rock guitar solos, so I thought I'd add my perspective here.

Gilmour has nothing on your ability to manipulate wood, though, Bubba. You will always have that.
 
the thing about Gilmour is that he always has such a soaring awesome sound.
Kinda easy to play something cool if it's sounding like that.
 
the thing about Gilmour is that he always has such a soaring awesome sound.
Kinda easy to play something cool if it's sounding like that.

Yeah kind of, but the big echoes are just the effects thrown in for effect. It still sounds good if you play those solos through a practice amp with a cheap guitar that's in tune. He gets a lot of mileage from a few notes. Angus Young has a beautiful habit of doing the same thing with a more rocking style.
 
Yeah kind of, but the big echoes are just the effects thrown in for effect. It still sounds good if you play those solos through a practice amp with a cheap guitar that's in tune. He gets a lot of mileage from a few notes. Angus Young has a beautiful habit of doing the same thing with a more rocking style.

I'll throw Neil Young in that category as well.

VP
 
Guitar notes are expensive. Spend them wisely. Dave is the king of less is more.
 
I think Comfortably Numb is a let-down. It doesn't have the same feeling of direction, the sense that you're being taken somewhere with it that you get on Time, or Another Brick, etc. It just seems like mindless fret-wanking by comparison. And it's too long. Way too long. :zzz:

Isn't that kinda the point? I mean, isn't that kinda the point of writing a song called "Comfortably NUMB?" It aint any dazzling solo, but it suits the point of the song perfectly.

And, poignantly, most of us are still today quite comfortably numb to what's going on around us. Choose your poison........ sit down, shut up, hang on.......
 
Neil Young's epilepsy gives him an unfair advantage.
 
Back
Top