Middleman
Professional Amateur
Well, I'm more musician than engineer so I had some production issues. The sound of the voices seemed a little too muddy when they were all in there together. Overall I liked it though and it shows a nice niche outside the normal metal, rock, or ballad vain so yeah I would definitely put it up there to show some range. It sounds more than fine.
Now on the production side of things, I know this is not your issue, but talk the guitar player in to backing off on the guitar to the point of just a few chordal references. I would make the kick and bass carry the tune more, kind of a bar sing along feel. Somewhat like the old hit Barbara Ann, where it sounds like everyone is sitting around and doing a sing along.
Maybe some handclapping, I don't know. A little more earthy and spontaneous sounding.
Enough of me. Good job.
Now on the production side of things, I know this is not your issue, but talk the guitar player in to backing off on the guitar to the point of just a few chordal references. I would make the kick and bass carry the tune more, kind of a bar sing along feel. Somewhat like the old hit Barbara Ann, where it sounds like everyone is sitting around and doing a sing along.
Maybe some handclapping, I don't know. A little more earthy and spontaneous sounding.
Enough of me. Good job.