mr8 thoughts for those considering
I've had mine for over a year now, and pro's cons in my experience are as follows:
Pros:
A great practice tool for laying down tracks, and developing skills and ideas.
Compact, portable.
8 digital tracks, what more can you say for $250
With additional investment Pros:
When i started bought a small mixer for preamps and started xferring tracks recorded in the MR8 to the PC, it opened things up greatly. I never even tried to use any of the mixing and effects in the MR8, hated them all, but incorporated with the software mixing options, I use the MR8 as an interface essentially, and have learned a great deal about the whole recording process that way.
Cons:
the $250, $300 whatever is the BEGINNING of the investment. If you are looking to record some guitar and bass tracks, or scratch tracks to develop songs or the like, the MR8 can stand on its own, but if you really want to stretch to somehting that really sounds good, expect to buy a mixer and/or preamps, decent monitoring, and consider the whole software mixing option. This quickly adds up to the amount you would pay for a decent PC interface setup, which seems to be why so many consier the switch to striaght PC after the "gateway" recorder of the MR8.
16 bit/44.1 - a limitation, espeically for the purists who hate the digital sound. Better A/D converters allow you to capture more of the signal.
Effects, amp and mic modelling, etc - just about useless IMO.
CF card reliance - at this point not a huge deal, many affordable (< $50) card will expand your recording options, and ify ou are willing to do some legwork xferring fiiles back and forth to the PC, easy to work around, but count a bigger card into the expense of the purchase.
YMMV, but my summation is that the MR8 is a fantastic deal for the casual recordist, and works great as a "notepad" for practice and song develoepment. It is a great incremental step to get into the whole thing, especially if you cannot afford to drop thousands right away to get a whole home recording package at higher quality, but does not stand on it's own at this point. In my case it has been fine, because i have been able to learna loit at a lower into proce before investing more into things i want down the road-- I can upgrade mics, pres, monitors, mixing software, etc one at a time around the MR8 and then replace it with the PC/Interface of my dreams and still be working with the MR8 the whole time. Even when i do that, i dount if i will get rid of it, and will likely enjoy the fact that I can move it around fairly easily.
Daav