"To be honest - I cannot see a lot of sense in doing the digital thing live, unless you can do it with at least the same quality as you can achieve analogue. Why go through 2 (bad) conversions?
If you want to do digital right live, you'd start at well over 100k!"
In spite of the your notion of 2 bad conversions the advantages are numerous. Unlike
the 02R (we have 3 in the studio I work at) the 01V is well laid out for live. The fact that I don't have to carry a back breaking rack of processing is enough to sell me. I carry 4 channels of outboard pre's to give me 16 inputs as well as EQ's for FOH and monitors. From one console I can run a main mix, 4 monitor mixes and a variety of output options for recording. It handles this with ease. A big plus has also been not getting noise caused by outboard gear. I have not had a hum problem in the 2 years of owning it. Again anytime I can get anything remotely close to it but in a larger format I'm ready to write the check. I'm willing to spend up to 5k.
Keep in mind any tool is as good as the the person using it. It's not a Midas or anything close to any kind of top shelf live console in performance or price. 100K is way out of my league for a live console but I"m guessing you probably know that. I have no desire to return to analog although a DDA would be tempting for the right price. (except I'd have to lug it around) I've rented plenty of consoles for larger shows and due to rider issues. You have to hire 2 extra stage hands just haul them in and out.
As is always the case with these Chevy Vs Porche comparisons, expectations and scope is often overlooked. If enemy of the sun has a bigger budget he's not said so. His choices would seem to preclude so. If he went Mackie 24/8 and even a small amount of outboard gear he'll end up double the price of
the 01V in a hurry. He'll get more channels,busses and less processing. Depends on where you want to trade off. After all that is the point. Everything has a trade off.
Any one who when asked for an opinion between Chevy and Ford, tells them they should forget about a car until they can afford a Rolls does no one a favor. I can fully accept that you dislike the Yamaha digital consoles. They wouldn't be my first choice either if there was something else better to choose from in this price class. Double even triple
PS: for anyone interested I should have some updates to my website
http://www.folkcafe.com online later tonight with some cool pictures of some gigs, recording sessions and new gear. Like the shop's new mobile recording rig. Genex GX8500's and Millenia 8 channel pre's. I hope I get to it before it gets too late.
Don Goguen
Folk Cafe Productions