
muttley600
Banned
Your not disagreeing with me at all, your disagreeing with known and accepted principles of the laws of physics and mechanics. It is these that largely define how the things work and how we can design and engineer things to perform the tasks we need them to.Slowrider said:Hey Muttley, have to disagree with you on that glue joint.
At no point has anyone said that this would be the case. We are talking about two different systems of attaching one material to another. Not the merits of one piece vs two pieces jointed together.That would be like saying a metal bar welded in a lap joint on the outside is as strong and resonance worthy as a solid piece of steel. Never going to happen.
Wrong. And what does "Solidity is only available, through a solid mass, such as string from nut to bridge." mean?? "Hide is best" who says?? It is a very good choice for many instrument applications and is as popular today as it was 400 years ago.If a guitar neck is screwed to the body with a Press Fit, it would only need 2 screws to hold the resonance charachteristics. Solidity is only available, through a solid mass, such as string from nut to bridge. You have to consider that any glue, "hide is best" or any gap...will induce loss of tone and sustain. That is why all guitar manufacturers claim to have more tonality and sustain.
I'm afraid I really don't understand what your driving at here. Sorry.
